Mary Sell: Allstate Insurance Logo

Mary Sell: Allstate Insurance

4.5(16 reviews)
UnclaimedInsurance brokerInsurance broker

What people love here...

Mary’s Honest, Needs-Based Sales Approach

Reviewers repeatedly highlight Mary’s genuine commitment to recommending only necessary coverage and maximizing savings.

She won’t sell you things you don’t want or need.
tries to do everything in her power to give you the best bang for your buck

Key Themes from Reviews

Professionalism & ExpertisePositive

Customers consistently praise Mary and her team for their high level of professionalism and insurance knowledge.

"Mary and her staff are extremely professional and helpful…"
"Great insurance agency. Mary is awesome to work with."

About Mary Sell: Allstate Insurance

Mary Sell: Allstate Insurance – Your Trusted Insurance Broker in Gilbertsville, PA

At Mary Sell: Allstate Insurance, located in the heart of Gilbertsville, PA, our mission is simple: to protect what matters most to you with honest, needs-based insurance solutions. As an experienced insurance broker, Mary Sell and her dedicated team bring deep expertise, personalized guidance, and unwavering professionalism to every client interaction. Whether you’re looking for auto, home, life, or business coverage, we leverage years of industry knowledge to ensure you get exactly what you need—no more, no less.

A Team Built on Professionalism & Expertise

From your very first conversation, you’ll notice the difference that comes from working with true insurance professionals. Mary Sell and her team have built a reputation for thorough knowledge of coverage options and regulatory requirements, allowing them to navigate even the most complex insurance challenges. Customers consistently praise our team’s expertise:

  • “Mary and her staff are extremely professional and helpful…”
  • “Great insurance agency. Mary is awesome to work with.”

Behind every policy is careful research, thoughtful comparison, and a commitment to finding the best fit for your situation. We don’t push unnecessary add-ons; instead, we focus on delivering precise solutions that bring you peace of mind.

Personalized & Trustworthy Advice

Insurance can be daunting. That’s why at Mary Sell: Allstate Insurance, you’ll never feel pressured or overwhelmed. Our personalized approach centers on understanding your unique circumstances and long-term goals.

  • “She won’t sell you things you don’t want or need…”
  • “They go above and beyond to try and help you with any issues.”

Whether you’re a first-time policyholder or reviewing a multi-policy package, Mary, Stan Suwala, Evelyn, and the rest of our collaborative team take the time to listen, explain, and tailor recommendations. This honest, transparent process builds trust—many clients tell us they finally feel empowered to make confident decisions about their coverage.

Exceptional Team Collaboration & Familiarity

Our culture thrives on collaboration. Stan Suwala and Mary Sell work hand in hand, combining their strengths to deliver comprehensive solutions that address every aspect of your risk management. With Evelyn’s expertise, you also receive detailed, clear explanations that demystify policy language and empower you to understand your protections fully. Clients appreciate this seamless teamwork:

  • “Stan Suwala and Mary Sell… are the best team!”
  • “Mary and Evelyn are so helpful… they give you ALL the information you need.”

From policy quotes to claims support, our office feels more like a community hub than a corporate outpost—a place where you’re greeted by name and treated like family.

Swift Responsiveness & Clear Communication

Life moves fast, and questions about coverage can’t wait. That’s why responsiveness is a cornerstone of our service. Whether you call, email, or stop by our Gilbertsville office, you’ll receive prompt, detailed answers that help you understand next steps and requirements:

  • “They always respond quickly and with enough details to know exactly what I need to do.”
  • “Answered all my questions, friendly and knowledgeable staff.”

Our goal is to remove uncertainty. By maintaining open lines of communication, we ensure you never feel left in the dark or scrambling for information at a critical moment.

Balancing Value & Pricing

At Mary Sell: Allstate Insurance, we understand that affordability matters as much as coverage. Many clients commend our ability to uncover cost-effective options and discounts:

  • “Best bang for your buck and/or deals to help you save money.”
  • “She tries to do everything in her power to give you the best bang for your buck.”

We conduct regular policy reviews to identify savings opportunities, from multi-policy bundling to safety feature discounts. While insurance premiums can be an investment, our priority is always to maximize value. A small number of clients have mentioned higher rates, but we welcome these conversations—it’s our chance to revisit your coverage, explore alternatives, and ensure your plan aligns with your budget and risk tolerance.

Reliable Follow-Through & Ongoing Support

Proactive support is important, and most clients applaud our dedication to follow-through:

  • “They go above and beyond to try and help you with any issues you might be having.”

On those rare occasions when we fall short, we take immediate action to rectify the situation. Your trust matters, and we continually refine our processes to ensure reliability across every step—from initial quote to claims resolution.

A Welcoming Office Atmosphere

Stepping into our Gilbertsville office, you’ll immediately feel at home. Our warm, inviting workspace reflects our commitment to genuine relationships and community ties. It’s not just about business transactions; it’s about building long-lasting partnerships. As one satisfied policyholder put it:

  • “This office made me really feel at home.”

Why Choose Mary Sell: Allstate Insurance?

  1. Deep Expertise: A professional team with years of insurance industry experience.
  2. Honest Advice: Needs-based recommendations without unnecessary upsells.
  3. Personal Attention: Tailored solutions and clear explanations that empower you.
  4. Prompt Communication: Fast, detailed responses to all your insurance questions.
  5. Value-Driven: Regular policy reviews to maximize coverage and identify savings.
  6. Collaborative Culture: A close-knit team that works together for your benefit.
  7. Community Focus: A friendly, home-like office environment in Gilbertsville, PA.

When you choose Mary Sell: Allstate Insurance, you’re not just getting a policy—you’re gaining a partner dedicated to safeguarding your future. Contact us today in Gilbertsville, PA, and discover the difference that professionalism, transparency, and genuine care can make in your insurance experience.

About This Business

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Service options

  • Onsite services
  • Online appointments

Contact Information

1569 Swamp Pike
Gilbertsville, PA 19525
United States of America
Claim This Business

Customer Reviews

4.5 out of 5 stars

Based on 16 reviews

Review data

5 star reviews

81%

4 star reviews

6%

3 star reviews

0%

2 star reviews

6%

1 star reviews

6%

Working Hours

Monday:
8:30AM-5PM
Tuesday:
8:30AM-5PM
Wednesday:
8:30AM-5PM
Thursday:
8:30AM-5PM
Friday:
9AM-5PM
Saturday:
Closed
Sunday:
Closed

Location Map