Peter Shaw - GEICO Insurance Agent Logo

Peter Shaw - GEICO Insurance Agent

4.9(581 reviews)
UnclaimedInsurance agencyInsurance agency

What people love here...

Jordan Sterner’s 24/7 Caring Support

Multiple customers single out Jordan for his genuine care and round-the-clock availability.

This guy is someone who you want as your insurance agent…I feel like I could call him at 3 in the morning and he would pick right up.
Jordan was extremely polite, helpful, and informative…most pleasant experience I’ve ever had.

Key Themes from Reviews

Staff Friendliness & ProfessionalismPositive

Customers consistently praise the agents for being warm, personable, and professional in all interactions.

"Mya was excellent and friendly."
"Staff was so friendly and wonderful and accommodating! Made me feel really comfortable…"

About Peter Shaw - GEICO Insurance Agent

About Peter Shaw – GEICO Insurance Agent in Wyomissing, PA

Nestled in the heart of Wyomissing, PA, Peter Shaw – GEICO Insurance Agent stands out as a full-service insurance agency dedicated to providing personalized coverage solutions for individuals, families, and businesses. Backed by GEICO’s industry-leading resources and Peter Shaw’s team of seasoned professionals, this office combines competitive rates with a genuine commitment to customer satisfaction.

Friendly, Professional Service from Day One

From the moment you step through the door—or pick up the phone—you’ll notice the difference. Mya and the rest of the team greet every caller and visitor with warmth and professionalism, making each interaction feel more like a conversation with a friend than a typical insurance transaction. As one customer put it, “Staff was so friendly and wonderful and accommodating! Made me feel really comfortable…” It’s this personable approach that turns first-time inquiries into lifelong relationships.

Deep Knowledge & Expert Guidance

Insurance can be complex, but at Peter Shaw – GEICO Insurance Agent, no question is too small and no policy too complicated. Agents like Bekka Long and Andrea take pride in breaking down coverages step by step, ensuring you fully understand your options. “They sat down with me, explained everything step by step. They have a lot of knowledge,” raves one client, while another highlights, “Bekka Long…very knowledgeable, very thorough, professional, and just has a wonderful attitude overall.” Whether you’re comparing auto deductibles or exploring umbrella policies, you’ll feel empowered to make informed decisions.

Competitive Rates & Real Cost Savings

One of the hallmarks of a true GEICO agency is competitive pricing—and Peter Shaw’s office delivers. Through savvy rate shopping and strategic bundling, clients consistently report significant premium reductions without sacrificing coverage. As one satisfied policyholder shared, “Pete and Mya helped me bundle my home & auto and save quite a bit off my monthly bill.” Another notes, “They saved me tons of money on car/home insurance with better coverage!” By leveraging GEICO’s robust underwriting and the local team’s hands-on approach, you’ll secure the best possible rates tailored to your unique needs.

Accessibility & Personalized Attention

Life moves fast, and insurance questions don’t always follow a 9-to-5 schedule. That’s why Peter Shaw’s office prides itself on accessibility. Whether you’re calling at lunchtime or need to meet offsite, the team goes the extra mile. One client was thrilled when Peter met them at their own office, joking, “Who does that? My agent does!” And for round-the-clock peace of mind, Jordan Sterner is on call 24/7. “I feel like I could call him at 3 in the morning and he would pick right up,” says one grateful policyholder.

Streamlined Claims Support & Local Advocacy

While corporate call centers can sometimes feel impersonal—“Terrible call on customer service 800 line in which I was in tears and hung up on,” laments one reviewer—your local GEICO office acts as your advocate. The team guides you through the claims process, follows up on approvals, and coordinates with GEICO’s national resources to speed up resolutions. You’ll never face claims alone.

A Welcoming, Family-Friendly Office Experience

A visit to Peter Shaw – GEICO Insurance Agent is more than just paperwork—it’s a comfortable, even fun, experience. Complimentary water, tea, and coffee are always on offer, and families are encouraged to bring along children. One delighted parent recalls, “My kids came along and were offered to play basketball—how awesome.” The office environment is thoughtfully designed to keep everyone at ease, ensuring policy setup and renewals are fast, friendly, and stress-free.

Innovative Tools to Enhance Your Coverage

Beyond personal service, the Wyomissing office leverages cutting-edge tools to simplify your insurance journey. Andrea’s recommendation of the GEICO Mobile App and the dive easy feature—highlighted by one reviewer as a game-changer—demonstrates the team’s dedication to providing value-added resources. With these apps at your fingertips, you can report claims, access ID cards, and manage policies with a few taps.

Why Choose Peter Shaw – GEICO Insurance Agent?

  • Unmatched Personal Touch: From Mya’s warm welcome to Peter’s willingness to meet offsite, experience a level of service you won’t find at a typical call center.
  • Expert Advice: Agents like Bekka Long and Andrea break down complex coverage options into clear, actionable steps.
  • Real Savings: Bundling and rate shopping translate into lower premiums and better protection.
  • 24/7 Support: Jordan Sterner’s around-the-clock availability means help is just a call away.
  • Family-Friendly Environment: Enjoy complimentary refreshments and a kids’ play area that turn insurance visits into a pleasant outing.
  • Local Claims Advocacy: Face claims with confidence, backed by a team that champions your interests.

Ready to Get Started?

Whether you’re looking to compare auto rates, bundle home and renters coverage, or explore specialized policies, Peter Shaw – GEICO Insurance Agent in Wyomissing, PA, is here to help. Contact the office today for a free, no-obligation quote and discover why so many in our community trust Peter Shaw for insurance done right.

Embrace peace of mind with an insurance agency that puts people first—call or stop by today!

About This Business

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Contact Information

2733 Paper Mill Rd Suite X3
Wyomissing, PA 19610
United States of America

Website: Visit Website

Claim This Business

Customer Reviews

4.9 out of 5 stars

Based on 581 reviews

Review data

5 star reviews

97%

4 star reviews

1%

3 star reviews

0%

2 star reviews

0%

1 star reviews

1%

Working Hours

Monday:
9AM-6PM
Tuesday:
9AM-6PM
Wednesday:
9AM-6PM
Thursday:
9AM-6PM
Friday:
9AM-6PM
Saturday:
10AM-2PM
Sunday:
Closed

Location Map