Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance Logo

Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance

4.8(108 reviews)

What people love here...

Exceptional Service from Staci

Staci’s proactive outreach and clear explanations stand out as a key driver of customer satisfaction.

“After dealing with Staci and all the help she has given me, I knew that I made the right decision.”
“She always touches base with me to keep me informed and that is greatly appreciated.”

Key Themes from Reviews

Staff Friendliness & ProfessionalismPositive

Customers consistently praise Hinkle team members for their warm, professional demeanor and willingness to help.

"“She has helped me with some great advice … She always touches base with me to keep me informed.”"
"“Your staff is always helpful and react to any issues we have in a timely manner.”"

About Hinkle Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance

Overview

Nestled in the heart of Lancaster, PA, Hinkle Insurance Agency – Erie Insurance has been a trusted partner for individuals, families, and businesses seeking comprehensive protection and peace of mind. As a full-service insurance agency, we specialize in auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, and commercial coverage, delivering customized solutions that meet the unique needs of each client. Whether you’re shopping for an affordable auto policy or exploring life insurance options, our commitment to friendly service, expert guidance, and competitive pricing ensures you’ll feel confident in your choices.

Comprehensive Insurance Solutions

At Hinkle Insurance Agency – Erie Insurance, we believe that quality coverage starts with understanding your world. Our role as an insurance broker and commercial agent extends far beyond policy issuance; we take the time to evaluate risks, explain coverage differences, and craft plans that protect what matters most.

  • Auto Insurance Agency: From liability to comprehensive protection and innovative add-ons like zero-deductible windshield replacement and free wiper installation, our auto plans are designed to give you worry-free driving.
  • Home Insurance Agency: Safeguard your home against storms, fires, and liability with policies tailored to your property’s value and your lifestyle.
  • Life Insurance Agency: Plan for tomorrow with term, whole, or universal life options that provide financial security for loved ones.
  • Commercial Agent: Let us help you manage business risks—from property and liability to specialized industry coverages—so you can focus on growth.

Why Choose Hinkle Insurance in Lancaster, PA?

  1. Staff Friendliness & Professionalism
    Our clients consistently highlight the warm, family-like atmosphere that greets them at every visit or phone call. “She always touches base with me to keep me informed,” raves one policyholder, illustrating our dedication to building relationships rather than simply selling policies.

  2. Knowledge & Expertise
    Making sense of insurance jargon is our specialty. We pride ourselves on breaking down complex coverages in clear terms. “Molly was super knowledgeable … she took the time to explain all the differences in coverages,” shares a satisfied customer—proof that our team goes the extra mile to empower you with understanding.

  3. Responsiveness & Communication
    In an industry where calling a big 1-800 number often leads to frustration, our promise is simple: reach a real person, fast. Whether you’re onboarding, renewing, or filing a claim, you’ll appreciate prompt, personalized responses. As one client put it, “Thank you Andrew for making the process smooth and communicating clearly.”

  4. Pricing & Value
    Exceptional coverage doesn’t have to cost a fortune. Our agents routinely identify savings opportunities, delivering broader protection at lower rates. “They are saving us a few hundred dollars a month for a better policy!” marvels another review, underscoring our commitment to value.

  5. Claims Process & Support
    Facing a claim—whether a flood in your basement or a fender bender—can be stressful. That’s why our partnership with Erie Insurance adjusters ensures a seamless, caring process. “It was seamless and stress free,” reports one customer who worked with our team through a complex claim.

Meet the Team Behind Your Coverage

  • Staci: As one of our lead agents, Staci’s proactive outreach and clear explanations have won her loyal fans. “After dealing with Staci and all the help she has given me, I knew that I made the right decision.”
  • Zachary Miller: Known for delivering impressive cost reductions and expanded coverage, Zachary has earned deep trust from clients who say, “Not only did he provide more expansive coverage, he cut my payment in half.”
  • Andrew Porter: When claims arise, Andrew’s hands-on approach transforms a difficult process into a manageable one. “With his help, a claim was processed and … made the process very seamless and stress free,” notes a relieved policyholder.

Personalized, Family-Focused Service

Our roots run deep in Lancaster County, and many customers have entrusted us with their insurance needs for decades. “I’ve been with Hinkle since I started driving over 40 years ago … always kept that ‘family’ feel,” recalls one long-time client. This family-centered culture means we remember your name, know your history, and follow up consistently to ensure your coverage stays aligned with life’s changes.

Real Customer Success Stories

  • Zero-Deductible Windshield Replacement & Free Wipers: “I just had my windshield replaced for $0 deductible AND complimentary new windshield wipers installed,” shares a delighted driver. These unexpected touches showcase our attention to detail and genuine care.
  • Ghosting an Adjuster? Rarely. While most clients praise our reliability—“Everyone there always has the answers I need”—we acknowledge that occasional lapses can occur. When they do, we own them and work swiftly to restore trust and deliver solutions.

Get Started Today

Choosing the right insurance partner can transform how you feel about protection. At Hinkle Insurance Agency – Erie Insurance in Lancaster, PA, we’re more than an insurance agency—we’re your advocates, advisors, and allies in risk management. Contact us today for a personalized quote and experience the warmth, expertise, and value that have made us a community favorite. Whether you’re searching for an auto insurance agency, home insurance agency, life insurance agency, commercial agent support, or a knowledgeable insurance broker, let Hinkle Insurance be the last stop on your quest for confidence and security.

About This Business

Crowd

  • LGBTQ+ friendly
  • Transgender safespace

Other

  • LGBTQ+ friendly
  • Identifies as women-owned

Amenities

  • Gender-neutral restroom

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Service options

  • Onsite services
  • Online appointments

From the business

  • Identifies as women-owned

Contact Information

705 Olde Hickory Rd
Lancaster, PA 17601
United States of America

Website: Visit Website

Claim This Business

Customer Reviews

4.8 out of 5 stars

Based on 108 reviews

Review data

5 star reviews

95%

4 star reviews

1%

3 star reviews

0%

2 star reviews

0%

1 star reviews

4%

Working Hours

Monday:
8:30AM-5PM
Tuesday:
8:30AM-5PM
Wednesday:
8:30AM-5PM
Thursday:
8:30AM-5PM
Friday:
8:30AM-4PM
Saturday:
Closed
Sunday:
Closed

Location Map