What people love here...

Jeimy Santiago’s Outstanding Service

Jeimy is repeatedly named for her patience, expertise, and ability to secure excellent coverage and savings.

Not only did she give me great customer service she helped me get great coverage for an affordable price… 10/10.
Jeimy was AWESOME! VERY PATIENT AND VERY HELPFUL! GAVE ME THE BEST QUOTE FOR FULL COVERAGE!

Key Themes from Reviews

Staff Friendliness & HelpfulnessPositive

Customers consistently praise staff for being approachable, friendly, and eager to assist with their insurance needs.

"Very kind and responsive customer service with great rates!"
"At this place the people are so nice and friendly."

About Acceptance Insurance

Acceptance Insurance in Lancaster, PA

Nestled in the heart of Lancaster, PA, Acceptance Insurance stands as a full-service insurance agency and broker, offering tailored coverage across multiple lines: auto insurance agency, health insurance agency, home insurance agency, life insurance agency, motorcycle insurance agency, and renter’s insurance agency. Whether you’re seeking dependable protection for your vehicle, your home, your family’s health, or your two-wheeled adventures, Acceptance Insurance combines local expertise with a friendly, compassionate approach—helping you secure the right policy at the right price.


Why You’ll Love Working with Acceptance Insurance

At Acceptance Insurance, the friendly atmosphere isn’t just a tagline—it’s at the core of every interaction. From the moment you walk in or pick up the phone, our team’s genuine warmth and willingness to assist shine through. Customers often remark, “The people here are so nice and friendly,” and they mean it. Whether you’re a first-time policyholder or you’ve been insured for decades, our staff greets you with a smile, listens with patience, and guides you confidently through the process.


Knowledgeable Agents Who Empower You

Insurance jargon can be daunting. That’s why our agents excel at breaking down policy details in plain English, transforming confusion into clarity. One client shared how our agent “educated me on what exactly my policy detailed,” saving them nearly $300 compared to a previous provider. Another highlighted how Miss Guzman “thoroughly explained every coverage option,” empowering them to choose exactly the right protection for their needs. At Acceptance Insurance, we believe that an informed customer makes the best decisions—and saving you money is our proudest achievement.


Affordability and Value: Insurance That Fits Your Budget

Affordability doesn’t mean cutting corners. At Acceptance Insurance, we specialize in finding competitive rates for drivers and homeowners of all profiles, regardless of credit history or driving record. As one satisfied customer put it, “Most affordable prices I’ve found in years! They work with everyone despite background or history.” In fact, many clients report savings of hundreds of dollars—one even exclaimed, “I saved over $300!” With our vast network of top carriers, we tailor coverage options that strike the perfect balance between comprehensive protection and budget-friendly premiums.


Personalized Service with Heart

Insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all. Our hallmark is empathy—taking the time to understand your unique circumstances and crafting solutions that truly support you. Recall the client who needed to pay in cash so as not to risk a lapse; our team stayed past closing time to help. Or the policyholder who said, “She was kind, patient, and very knowledgeable… genuinely looks out for what is in your best interest.” That’s the Acceptance Insurance commitment: a level of personalized attention you won’t find at big-box insurers.


Celebrating Our Service Champions

We’re proud that our team members shine in customer feedback, elevating the entire agency’s reputation for excellence.

• Jeimy Santiago’s Outstanding Service
Jeimy’s patients and expertise consistently earn rave reviews. Clients say she’s “awesome, very patient and very helpful,” and that she secured “great coverage for an affordable price… 10/10.” Her ability to navigate complex coverage options swiftly and courteously makes her a standout resource for anyone seeking auto, home, or health insurance.

• Antoinette Santos’ Compassionate Expertise
Professionalism meets heart in every interaction with Antoinette. Customers describe her as “truly amazing,” noting how she never rushes you and always explains each quote until you feel confident. One client shared that speaking with her “felt like a family friend was helping me.”

• Shadia Guzman’s Multitasking Empathy
When demands run high, Shadia stays cool under pressure, juggling multiple tasks while still making you feel heard. Reviewers cheer, “Ask for Shadia! I still can’t believe how cheap my full policy for my jet ski and business is.” Her empathy and efficiency earn her “10 stars,” even on the busiest days.


Rapid Renters Insurance Issuance

For those in need of quick coverage, our renter’s insurance agency service is the solution. Imagine securing a renters policy in just 10 minutes—no fuss, no waiting. Customers rave, “Amazing and fast!! Got a renters policy in about 10 mins. Would definitely recommend.” Whether you’re moving across town or leasing your first apartment, we’ll have you covered before you know it.


Striving for Continuous Improvement

While we take pride in our high marks for friendliness, knowledge, and savings, we’re equally committed to refining our accessibility and claims support. We’ve listened to feedback about wait times and phone system challenges and are proactively upgrading our digital tools and expanding support hours. Our goal is to ensure that every call and online request meets the same high standard you experience in person.


Secure Your Peace of Mind Today

Acceptance Insurance isn’t just an insurance broker—it’s your dedicated partner in protecting what matters most. From Lancaster’s bustling streets to the rural roads beyond, our auto insurance agency coverage keeps you moving, our home and renter’s insurance agencies guard your property, our health and life insurance agencies safeguard your well-being, and our motorcycle insurance agency fuels your sense of adventure.

Stop by our Lancaster, PA office or give us a call to experience the Acceptance Insurance difference: expert guidance, genuine compassion, and coverage designed around you. Let us help you find the protection—and the peace of mind—you deserve.

About This Business

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Service options

  • Onsite services
  • Language assistance: Spanish

Contact Information

454 N Prince St
Lancaster, PA 17603
United States of America

Website: Visit Website

Claim This Business

Customer Reviews

4.5 out of 5 stars

Based on 165 reviews

Review data

5 star reviews

80%

4 star reviews

8%

3 star reviews

2%

2 star reviews

1%

1 star reviews

10%

Working Hours

Monday:
9AM-6PM
Tuesday:
9AM-6PM
Wednesday:
9AM-6PM
Thursday:
9AM-6PM
Friday:
9AM-6PM
Saturday:
10AM-2PM
Sunday:
Closed

Location Map