Beiler Insurance Agency Logo

Beiler Insurance Agency

4.5(39 reviews)
UnclaimedInsurance agencyInsurance agency

What people love here...

Personalized Care from Dianne

Multiple reviewers single out Dianne for her patient, proactive communication and genuine client concern.

Dianne takes the most amazing care of her clients … she has my account handled + will notify me any time there are any changes.
She was happy to ease my concerns and answer every single question I had.

Key Themes from Reviews

Staff Friendliness & ProfessionalismPositive

Customers consistently praise the agency’s staff for being warm, approachable, and highly professional.

"Very helpful group. Friendly, and ready to assist whenever I call. It is a pleasure to work with Beiler Insurance."
"Wonderful people to take care of insurance."

About Beiler Insurance Agency

### About Beiler Insurance Agency  
Nestled in the heart of Gap, PA, Beiler Insurance Agency has built a sterling reputation as a full-service insurance agency committed to protecting what matters most to families and businesses alike. From your first call to long after a policy is in place, the Beiler team blends hometown warmth with deep industry expertise—delivering coverage solutions tailored to each client’s unique needs. Whether you’re shopping for auto, home, business, or life insurance, Beiler Insurance Agency offers a seamless, professional experience backed by real people who care.

### Friendly, Professional Staff  
What sets Beiler Insurance Agency apart is the genuine warmth and professionalism of its people. Clients consistently praise the friendly atmosphere and expert guidance they receive from every team member. One local resident raves, “It is a pleasure to work with Beiler Insurance,” while another notes, “Wonderful people to take care of insurance.” From the moment you pick up the phone, you’ll be greeted by approachable professionals who take the time to listen, understand your concerns, and walk you through your options with patience and respect.

### Rapid, Clear Communication  
In the fast-moving world of insurance, nothing beats prompt, transparent communication. At Beiler Insurance Agency, calls and emails never languish in an inbox. As one satisfied client puts it, “No one responds faster when I place a call or send an e-mail!” This commitment to responsiveness ensures you’re never left wondering about policy details, renewal deadlines, or new coverage opportunities. Team members like Andrew, Margie, and Micah are known for their rapid follow-up—so you always feel informed and confident about your insurance decisions.

### Personalized, Proactive Service  
Insurance can feel overwhelming, but the Beiler Insurance Agency team turns complexity into clarity. Instead of one-size-fits-all recommendations, staff members take a proactive, hands-on approach. Dianne, for example, tracks industry changes and personally notifies clients of any updates or savings opportunities—often scheduling calls around even the busiest calendars. She “takes the most amazing care of her clients,” ensuring every question is answered and every concern is eased. When you partner with Beiler, you gain an advocate who anticipates your needs and continually reviews your coverage to keep you protected.

### Expert Guidance That Saves You Money  
Quality coverage doesn’t have to come at a premium price. Many clients credit Andrew with uncovering significant savings through careful policy reviews and smart bundling strategies. “He saved me hundreds of dollars,” one customer exclaims, while another recalls, “Andrew walked me through the whole process and doubled my coverage for less.” By comparing multiple carriers, negotiating competitive rates, and explaining the fine print with crystal-clear clarity, the Beiler team helps you secure maximum protection at the best possible price.

### Seamless, Efficient Processes  
From getting a quick quote to managing your policy, Beiler Insurance Agency makes insurance hassle-free. Customers describe the experience as “streamlined” and “easy,” praising the agency’s efficient online tools and attentive follow-through. Whether you need to add a new driver, file a homeowner’s claim, or review your business liability limits, the process is designed to be straightforward. With clear instructions and minimal red tape, you can focus on living your life or running your business—confident that your coverage is in good hands.

### Dedicated Support Across All Lines  
Beiler Insurance Agency serves a diverse clientele, from first-time auto purchasers to seasoned business owners. Margie, a go-to specialist for commercial policies, earns accolades for being “always available for questions and immediate help.” Micah Hostetter stands out for breaking down complex coverage options into plain language, so you truly understand what you’re buying. Whether it’s personal auto, homeowner, flood, umbrella, or employee benefit plans, the agency’s collective expertise ensures every policy reflects industry best practices and local market insights.

### Real Impact, Real Testimonials  
• “It’s a pleasure to work with Beiler Insurance—friendly, ready to assist whenever I call.”  
• “Dianne notifies me anytime there are changes. She’s so patient with my busy schedule.”  
• “Andrew saved me a lot of money and explained things I didn’t understand.”  
• “Margie is the best—she is always available for questions and immediate help.”  
• “Micah helped me make the best decision by discussing all of my options in detail.”

### Why Choose Beiler Insurance Agency?  
In Gap, PA, you have many choices for insurance—and yet Beiler Insurance Agency continues to stand out. Their hallmark combination of approachable professionals, lightning-fast responsiveness, proactive policy monitoring, and cost-saving expertise means you’re not just another policy number. You’re a valued client whose protection and peace of mind matter. By blending cutting-edge tools with old-fashioned customer care, Beiler Insurance Agency has become a trusted partner for individuals, families, and businesses throughout Lancaster County and beyond.

Ready to experience insurance the way it should be—simple, personal, and genuinely supportive? Contact Beiler Insurance Agency today for a free, no-obligation quote and discover why so many in Gap, PA, trust them to safeguard their most important assets.

About This Business

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Service options

  • Onsite services

Contact Information

5406 Lincoln Hwy
Gap, PA 17527
United States of America

Website: Visit Website

Claim This Business

Customer Reviews

4.5 out of 5 stars

Based on 39 reviews

Review data

5 star reviews

82%

4 star reviews

0%

3 star reviews

10%

2 star reviews

0%

1 star reviews

8%

Working Hours

Monday:
8AM-5PM
Tuesday:
8AM-5PM
Wednesday:
8AM-5PM
Thursday:
8AM-5PM
Friday:
8AM-5PM
Saturday:
Closed
Sunday:
Closed

Location Map