Gibbel Insurance Agency Inc

Overview

Nestled in the heart of Lititz, PA, Gibbel Insurance Agency Inc is your hometown ally for protecting what matters most. As a full-service insurance agency, we specialize in Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Health Insurance, Life Insurance, Motorcycle Insurance, and Renter’s Insurance. For decades, neighbors and businesses across Lancaster County have relied on our deep industry expertise, personalized attention, and commitment to delivering real value. Whether you’re shopping for your first policy or seeking to optimize existing coverage, Gibbel Insurance Agency Inc offers fast, friendly service and tailored solutions that put you—and your peace of mind—first.

Comprehensive Coverage Tailored to You

At Gibbel Insurance Agency Inc, we know that no two clients are alike. That’s why our agents invest the time to understand your unique needs and budget before recommending coverage.

• Auto Insurance Agency: From compact cars to luxury SUVs, we’ll design a policy that balances premium savings with the right limits and deductibles.
• Home Insurance Agency: Whether you own a single-family dwelling or a rental property, our tailored home policies protect your investment against fire, theft, liability, and more.
• Health Insurance Agency: We guide you through benefit options and network considerations, ensuring you get quality care without breaking the bank.
• Life Insurance Agency: Provide financial security for loved ones with term, whole, or universal life plans that match your goals.
• Motorcycle Insurance Agency: Hit the open road with confidence, backed by comprehensive coverage that safeguards you on every ride.
• Renter’s Insurance Agency: Even tenants deserve robust protection—our renter’s policies cover personal belongings, liability, and loss of use at competitive rates.

Our Core Strengths

1. Staff Expertise & Professionalism
   “She was very fast, knowledgeable, and took all the stress out of searching for the right insurance.” Customers consistently applaud our agents’ industry know-how and genuine professionalism. From initial consultation to claims support, you’ll experience courteous guidance and clear explanations at every step.
2. Pricing & Value
   “Gibbel Insurance agency saved me $5,000 per year! … gave me the same coverage for $5,000 less.” We continually shop top carriers to secure discounted rates and uncover opportunities to enhance your coverage without raising premiums.
3. Responsiveness & Turnaround
   “I was called within maybe 30 minutes of requesting a quote online.” In today’s busy world, time is precious. Our team commits to same-day service and quick callbacks so that your insurance decisions never stall.
4. Ease of Process & Stress Reduction
   “She made everything so easy and clear, and took the time to make sure I understood everything.” We break down complex insurance jargon into plain language, guiding you through forms, deadlines, and renewals to eliminate surprises.
5. Personalized & Customer-Centric Service
   “They take care of cancelling my previous insurance … so I had time to concentrate on my business.” From proactive outreach to concierge-style handling of policy changes, our agents treat you like family—warm, attentive, and always one call away.
6. Coverage Customization & Clarity
   “Helped me tailor some insurance policies … at a significant savings.” We don’t believe in one-size-fits-all: our specialists craft bespoke packages that align coverage limits, deductibles, and endorsements with your lifestyle.

Continuous Improvement

Even the best teams look for ways to refine their processes. We’ve heard feedback about occasional delays in cancellation and renewal communications, and we’ve taken immediate action. Our back-office systems now feature automated reminders and follow-up protocols to ensure every request is handled swiftly—so you can move on with confidence.

Meet Your Trusted Advisors

• Jen Strickler: Known for her promptness, expertise, and engaging personality, Jen turns insurance shopping into a stress-free experience. “Jen is prompt, extremely knowledgeable, fun yet professional…”
• Bill Barshinger: A master at uncovering savings, Bill has helped countless families and business owners shave thousands off their premiums. “My husband and I had the best experience with Bill! He was able to save us thousands of dollars each year…”
• Beverly Leontis: Our renewal-alert specialist, Beverly proactively contacts clients well before policy expiration, delivering hundreds of dollars in annual savings. “She emailed me reminding me of my upcoming auto policy renewal. She said she could save me hundreds and that’s exactly what she did!”

Free Quote & Coverage Audit Service

One of our most popular offerings is the no-cost Quote & Audit. We compare your current policy against multiple carriers, pinpointing gaps or overlaps in coverage:

• “They gave us a FREE quote and comparison chart … we were UNDER insured! They saved us $300 AND gave us BETTER coverage!!”
• “They reviewed our rental property again … saved us over $1000!!”

You’ll receive a concise, side-by-side analysis that reveals immediate savings and improved protection—no obligation, no hidden fees.

Join the Gibbel Family Today

Choosing the right insurance partner can make all the difference when life throws the unexpected your way. At Gibbel Insurance Agency Inc in Lititz, PA, our mission is simple: protect your future with expertise, integrity, and genuine care. Whether you need a new Auto Insurance policy, a comprehensive Home Insurance package, or specialized coverage like Motorcycle or Renter’s Insurance, our team is ready to serve.

Ready to experience the Gibbel difference? Contact us now for your free quote and personalized coverage audit. Let us turn insurance complexity into clear, cost-effective solutions—so you can focus on what matters most.