CrossKeys Insurance Inc Logo

CrossKeys Insurance Inc

4.8(110 reviews)

What people love here...

Vanessa Pagan’s Outstanding Service

Multiple reviewers name-check Vanessa for her reliability, responsiveness, and personalized attention.

Vanessa Pagan has been my agent, and now my daughter’s, for years. She’s incredibly helpful and provides us with the best care and service.
Call for Vanessa she is the best agent in my own opinion, and she will always find you the best rate possible.

Key Themes from Reviews

Customer Service ResponsivenessPositive

Customers consistently praise the agency for quick, courteous, and helpful responses whenever they reach out.

"My agent is always helpful and attentive, getting back to me with any questions I have in a timely fashion…"
"Your customer service is fantastic. I never feel like a number or another policy."

About CrossKeys Insurance Inc

CrossKeys Insurance Inc: Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Reading, PA

Located in the heart of Reading, PA, CrossKeys Insurance Inc has built a sterling reputation as a full-service insurance agency. Whether you’re searching for an auto insurance agency, home insurance agency, life insurance agency—or an agency that can bundle them all—CrossKeys delivers expert guidance and friendly, personalized care at every turn. Over the years, clients have come to rely on CrossKeys Insurance Inc not just for comprehensive coverage but for a relationship-driven approach that turns insurance from a necessity into a genuine peace-of-mind experience.

Comprehensive Insurance Solutions

At CrossKeys Insurance Inc, our suite of services is designed to meet life’s many twists and turns:

  • Auto Insurance Agency: Competitive rates, flexible deductibles, and optional extras like rental reimbursement and roadside assistance.
  • Home Insurance Agency: Customized protection for homeowners, renters, and landlords, from basic hazards to high-value collectibles.
  • Life Insurance Agency: Term life, whole life, and universal life policies crafted around your family’s future, budget, and long-term goals.
  • Business and Specialty Coverage: Tailored solutions for small businesses or niche concerns.

By offering this broad spectrum of products under one roof, we streamline your experience—and often secure cost savings by bundling policies.

A Responsive Team, Always There for You

A hallmark of CrossKeys Insurance Inc is our unwavering commitment to customer service responsiveness. Clients consistently praise our prompt, courteous, and thorough replies. “My agent is always helpful and attentive, getting back to me with any questions I have in a timely fashion,” raves one longtime policyholder. Another notes, “Your customer service is fantastic. I never feel like a number or another policy.” That level of attentiveness transforms routine inquiries into reassuring conversations—and turns first-time callers into lifelong clients.

Personalized, Relationship-Driven Service

At CrossKeys Insurance Inc, we believe that true value emerges when insurance becomes personal. We know our clients by name, not by policy number. Many customers say they “feel like part of the family” from the moment they walk through our doors or call our office. You won’t be transferred to an 800 number or shuffled between generic representatives. Instead, you’ll work one-on-one with knowledgeable agents like Vanessa Pagan, whose reliable, hands-on approach has earned her praise as “the best agent imaginable” and “incredibly helpful.”

Expert Agents Who Advocate for You

Navigating insurance options can be complex—but you’re never alone with CrossKeys by your side. Our staff expertise and knowledge are consistently cited as key strengths. Clients mention Steve Yeity specifically, applauding his “great customer service and a ton of knowledge,” and credit him for going “the extra mile” during stressful claims situations. Whether you’re exploring life insurance riders or adjusting auto coverage levels, our team explains every detail clearly and objectively—never resorting to hard-sell tactics.

Rapid, Seamless Claims Handling

A true test of an insurance company is how quickly and smoothly it handles claims. CrossKeys Insurance Inc shines in this area, too. One client recalls placing a claim on a Sunday afternoon, only to have their car in the shop by Monday evening. Another, after a rear-end collision, praised the “instant setup” of a rental car and said, “It was really an easy process.” We maintain close partnerships with leading carriers to ensure your claims are managed efficiently, with consistent communication so you always know what to expect.

Competitive Pricing and Real Value

From lowering auto premiums to securing long-overdue life coverage at a reasonable rate, our clients consistently find that CrossKeys delivers more value for their dollar. Competitive pricing isn’t just about the lowest premium—it’s about the right coverage, minimizing out-of-pocket costs, and maximizing benefits. Our agents conduct regular policy reviews, hunting for discounts and adjustments that reflect your evolving lifestyle, driving habits, or life stage.

Effortless Onboarding and Policy Transfers

Switching insurance agencies can feel daunting—but not with CrossKeys Insurance Inc. New customers often highlight our smooth, hassle-free transfer process. As one client shares, “CrossKeys made moving my insurance policy very easy,” and credits Tim Flynn’s expertise for a “smooth and quick transaction.” We handle every phone call, form, and fax, freeing you to focus on what matters most—your family, your home, and your business.

Communication & Follow-Through

While no company is perfect, the overwhelming feedback highlights our dedication to clear, consistent communication. We follow up on every inquiry, track every claim, and keep you informed at every stage. If occasional hiccups arise, our leadership steps in immediately to resolve any breakdowns—because at CrossKeys, your confidence is our highest priority.

Join the CrossKeys Family Today

When you choose CrossKeys Insurance Inc in Reading, PA, you’re not just buying a policy—you’re gaining a trusted ally. From auto insurance and home insurance to life insurance solutions, our responsive team, personalized service, expert agents, efficient claims handling, and competitive pricing add up to an insurance experience that’s as unique as you are.

Discover how easy and rewarding insurance can be. Contact CrossKeys Insurance Inc today, and let us tailor a plan that protects what matters most—your car, your home, your loved ones, and your peace of mind.

About This Business

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Contact Information

5035 Pottsville Pike
Reading, PA 19605
United States of America

Website: Visit Website

Claim This Business

Customer Reviews

4.8 out of 5 stars

Based on 110 reviews

Review data

5 star reviews

92%

4 star reviews

5%

3 star reviews

2%

2 star reviews

0%

1 star reviews

2%

Working Hours

Monday:
8:30AM-5PM
Tuesday:
8:30AM-5PM
Wednesday:
8:30AM-5PM
Thursday:
8:30AM-5PM
Friday:
8:30AM-4PM
Saturday:
Closed
Sunday:
Closed

Location Map