Hearts & Minds

About Hearts & Minds

Nestled in the heart of Dallastown, PA, Hearts & Minds is more than just a book store—it’s a community cornerstone where stories come alive. From its floor-to-ceiling shelves to its inviting reading nooks, this independent bookstore specializes in both Christian and secular titles, thoughtfully curated to satisfy passionate bibliophiles and casual browsers alike. Whether you’re searching for a rare theological commentary or the latest bestselling novel, Hearts & Minds delivers an unparalleled selection wrapped in genuine small-town warmth.

Expert Staff & Personalized Service

At the core of Hearts & Minds’ reputation is its knowledgeable, friendly team. Owners Byron Borger and Beth have earned glowing praise for their passion and expertise. Customers often say, “Byron Borger is one of the most well-read and insightful people I have come across,” and his tailored recommendations keep readers coming back time and again. Beth’s warm welcome and uncanny knack for matching the right book to the right person have forged lasting relationships, turning one-time visitors into loyal regulars. From in-person consultations to email exchanges, the staff’s thoughtful guidance transforms book shopping into a truly personal experience.

A Curated Selection to Delight Every Reader

One glance at the densely packed shelves and you’ll understand why Hearts & Minds has become a destination bookstore. Reviewers rave about the “huge selection of books (floor to ceiling)” and celebrate the depth and breadth of titles available. Beyond popular fiction and non-fiction, the store prides itself on hard-to-find theology texts, in-depth biographies, scholarly commentaries, and beautifully illustrated children’s books. If a customer requests a title that’s not currently in stock, Byron and Beth spring into action—sourcing directly from publishers or special distributors to ensure that if “it doesn’t exist,” they’ll help you discover its closest alternative.

Safe and Convenient Ordering & Pickup

During the challenges of COVID-19, Hearts & Minds pivoted quickly to a curbside-only browsing model. While some customers missed free-range in-store browsing—calling it “a bit frustrating”—they applauded the store’s commitment to safety and service. If you can’t pop in, a quick call from the parking lot, an email, or a phone request is all it takes. Byron personally oversees each order, packaging and shipping books nationwide with care. As one satisfied shopper noted, “If you can’t visit in person, Byron will ship books to you and provide you with the most excellent recommendations!” This level of attentiveness ensures that every reader, near or far, feels right at home.

A Welcoming Atmosphere & Community Hub

Step inside when browsing restrictions lift, and you’ll find an inspiring, comfortable environment where ideas flourish. Customers say they could “spend hours there,” soaking up the quiet energy of thoughtful exploration. The plush chairs, gentle lighting, and softly playing background music invite you to linger—whether you’re diving into a newly discovered author or flipping through the latest local history volume. Hearts & Minds doesn’t just sell books; it cultivates an atmosphere where people come to learn, reflect, and connect.

Fair Pricing & Exclusive Member Benefits

Great books deserve great value, and Hearts & Minds strikes that balance perfectly. With fair pricing across new releases and hardbacks, plus frequent member discounts—like 20% off most new or promoted titles—the bookstore ensures every purchase feels like a smart investment. On special occasions, customers have even saved up to 35% off list prices when Byron arranged direct‐from‐publisher purchases for large orders. Whether you’re stocking up for your home library or gifting a treasured title, you’ll appreciate the transparent pricing and occasional sales that make literature accessible to all.

Unique Events & Thought-Provoking Content

Beyond retail, Hearts & Minds extends its influence through a vibrant events calendar and the acclaimed blog, Booknotes. From author meet-and-greets to signing sessions, the store has hosted luminaries such as N.T. Wright, drawing crowds eager for conversation and insight. As one guest attendee reflected, “Byron invited N.T. Wright for a meet, greet, signing, and talk. It was amazing.” Meanwhile, the Booknotes blog offers in-depth reviews, author interviews, and curated reading lists—providing a digital space where the community can engage with ideas long after the store’s doors close.

Plan Your Visit

Whether you’re a local resident of Dallastown, PA, or a visitor exploring York County, Hearts & Minds invites you to discover the magic of a truly personal book store. Browse thoughtfully selected titles, lean on Byron and Beth’s expertise, and join a community of readers who appreciate the art of thoughtful discovery. Stop by during store hours for in-person browsing—or take advantage of their seamless curbside pickup and mail-order service. For book lovers of all ages and interests, Hearts & Minds is where knowledge meets heart, and every page turns into possibility.