the bagel bar cafe Menu

New York Crumb Cake

You are going to love this old fashioned recipe ...a mountain of brown sugar crumbs piled high on top of a rich and buttery cake.

Apple Cinnamon Muffin

Banana Muffin

Fresh-baked Banana Muffin.

Blueberry Muffins

Fresh-baked Blueberry muffin!

Chocolate Chip Muffin

Fresh-baked Chocolate Chip Muffin!

Peanut Butter Muffin

Double Chocolate Chip Muffins

Freshly baked double chocolate chip muffins

Cinnamon Bun Muffin

A freshly baked muffin full of delicious swirls of cinnamon and brown sugar and an iced streusel topping

Chocolate Chunk Fudge Brownie

Soft, chewy and truly indulgent.

Biscotti

Anita s homemade biscotti are made locally with recipes that are packed with wholesome ingredients -- real butter, real eggs, real chocolate, real flavorings, real dried fruits... rich in flavor, light and crunchy in texture and delicately sweet. They pair perfectly with your favorite coffee!

Chocolate-Covered Espresso Beans Small (Quarter-Pound)

Chocolate-Covered Espresso Beans Large (Half-Pound)

★ Buttery Sugar BB Cup Cookies

Walley s Sweets Treats has done it again! Jess hand-crafted a replica of our to-go cup and it melts in your mouth and looks adorable too!

★ Buttery Sugar BB Campfire Mug Cookies

Walley s Sweets Treats has done it again! Jess hand-crafted a replica of our green campfire mug. It melts in your mouth and looks adorable too!

★ Birthday Cake Marshmallow

Birthday cake filling topped with an adorable marshmallow cupcake!

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough(Macaron)

S mores

★ Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup (Macaron)

Peanut butter cups and chocolate! Need we say more??? Just say YES!

★ Cocohaze (Macaron)

coconut buttercream cookie with a hazelnut filling topped with toasted coconut! Pairs perfectly with our Cocohaze August Drink Special

★ Cookie Butter (Macaron)

cookie butter buttercream with a cookie butter filling topped with a Biscoff cookie! Pairs perfectly with our Cookie Butter Shaken Espresso August drink special!

★ Tootsie Chai (Macaron)

Vanilla chai cookie with a chocolate ganache filling topped with a mini tootsie roll! This one pairs perfectly with the Tootsie Chai August drink special!

★ Milky Way (Macaron)

Chocolate buttercream with a caramel filling topped with a mini Milky Way! This one pairs perfectly with our Milky Way August drink special!

★ Leo (Macaron)

Mango dragonfruit buttercream with a lemon curd filling! This one pairs perfectly with our Leo {shaken iced mango dragonfruit lemonade} August drink special!

★ Big Bagel Bundle (18 bagels, 1.5 lbs cream cheese)

PLEASE ORDER BEFORE 2pm THE DAY BEFORE PICKUP. We cannot fulfill large bagel orders the same day they are ordered. Thank you! This bundle includes 18 bagels with a half pound of plain cream cheese and your choice of two half-pounds of flavored cream cheese. Simply list your choice of bagels (flavors and quantity) in the Special Requests box.

★ Baby Bagel Bundle (13 bagels, 1 lb of cream cheese)

PLEASE ORDER BEFORE 2pm THE DAY BEFORE PICKUP. We cannot fulfill large bagel orders the same day they are ordered. Thank you! The Baby Bagel Bundle includes a baker s dozen (13) bagels with half a pound of plain cream cheese and a half pound of your choice of flavored cream cheese. Simply list your choice of bagels (flavors and quantity) in the Special Requests box. Please order 24 hours in advance. Thank you!

★ Brunch in a Box Budle *Advance Order Required

*PLEASE ORDER BEFORE 2pm THE DAY BEFORE PICKUP. We are unable to fulfill large bagel orders the same day they are ordered. Thank you! * Our Brunch in a Box Bundles include a box of hot coffee, 8 assorted bagels, 8 muffins, 2- 1/2 lb. tubs of cream cheese and all the fixins {cups, sugar, creamer, knives and napkins}

The GOAT

Open-face bagel with tomatoes, avocado, goat cheese spread and crumbles drizzled with a sweet balsamic glaze.

★ The All American

This skyscraper of a sandwich includes local, thinly-sliced ham, turkey breast, dill pickles, lettuce, tomato, onions, American cheese, mayo and mustard on your favorite NY Bagel!

Egg and Cheese(American)

Perfectly cooked eggs with melty cheese between your choice of 24 bagel varieties, croissants, or toast.

Egg, Veggies Cheese(American)

Eggs, green pepper, onion, tomato, and cheese between two halves of your favorite bagel, a croissant, or toast.

Ham, Egg Cheese(American)

Eggs, ham, and beautifully melty cheese on your choice of bagel, croissant, or toast.

Bacon, Egg Cheese(American)Popular

Is this really something we need to spell out for you?

Sausage, Egg Cheese(American)Popular

A New York classic. On your favorite bagel, croissant, or toast.

Pork Roll, Egg Cheese(American)Popular

You might know it as Taylor Ham.

Sausage Cheese(American)

Two sausage patties with cheese on your favorite bagel, croissant, or toast.

Bacon Cheese(American)

More bacon than you might even want with cheese between two halves of your favorite bagel, croissant, or toast.

Pork Roll Cheese(American)

Plenty of pork roll (or Taylor Ham , depending on where you re from) with cheese. On your choice of bagel, croissant, or toast.

Lite Breakfast(American cheese)

Egg whites, turkey, tomato, and cheese with French s Yellow Mustard. On your choice of bagel, croissant, or toast

Egg Western Works(American)

Eggs, ham, green pepper, tomato, and onion with cheese. Yeah, like the omelet, only this comes on a bagel, croissant, or toast.

The Pink Flamingo(American)

The brain-child of a local gym owner, fitness guru, and KU athletics coach, this bagelwich has eggs, sausage, ham, turkey, and cheese. PLUS... wait for it... strawberry cream cheese!

The FULL Flamingo(American)

If you thought our Pink Flamingo was over the top, try adding pork roll and bacon. This breakfast conglomeration has eggs, sausage, ham, turkey, bacon, pork roll, and cheese with strawberry cream cheese. All, somehow, stacked between to halves of your favorite bagel.

Avocado Bagel Toast

Toasted open-faced bagel with butter, smashed avocado and a sprinkle of everything bagel seasoning.

Avocado Bagel Toast

Toasted open-faced bagel with butter, fresh avocado and a sprinkle of everything bagel seasoning.

Toasted Bagel w/ Cream CheesePopular

Choose from our wide selection of Lancaster county-made cream cheeses.

Toasted Bagel w/ Butter

Chose your favorite toasted bagel topped with just the right amount of butter.

Hummus on a Toasted Bagel

Our homemade red pepper hummus spread atop your favorite, fresh NY bagel.

Butter, Cinnamon Sugar on a Toasted Bagel

Butter, cinnamon, and sugar spread atop your favorite toasted bagel.

Strawberry Preserves or Grape Jelly on Bagel

Preserves or Grape Jelly on your choice of toasted bagel.

Toasted Bagel w/ Peanut Butter

The classic, smooth treat artfully spread atop your favorite toasted bagel.

PB J

Peanut Butter and Jelly between two halves of the best toasted bagel in town. It s a simple classic for a reason.

Toasted Bagel w/ Nutella

That smooth, chocolatey hazelnut spread on your favorite toasted bagel.

Toasted ***nothing on it*** JUST TOASTED

N.Y. Lox n Cream CheesePopular

Nova Scotian smoked salmon with tomato, onion, and cream cheese on your choice of 24 fresh-baked bagels.

The GOAT

Open-face bagel with tomatoes, avocado, goat cheese spread and crumbles drizzled with a sweet balsamic glaze.

Veggiewich

Your choice of fresh New York bagel with green peppers, tomatoes, cucumber, onion, sprouts, and veggie cream cheese.

Hummus Special

Open-faced with homemade hummus, cucumber, tomato, and sprouts on your bagel choice.

Triple Cheese Veggie

American, swiss, and provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato, onion, and mayo on your favorite fresh-baked bagel.

The B.L.T.

The classic. With plenty of bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on your choice of a fresh-baked bagel.

Tuna Meltaway

Our famous, local tuna salad with melted American cheese, open-faced on your favorite fresh bagel.

The Tunawich

Our famous tuna salad with lettuce and tomato on your choice of fresh-baked bagel.

Turkey Club

This skyscraper of a sandwich includes local, thin-sliced turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and mayo.

The T.H.C.

No relation to its molecular homonym. This sandwich includes turkey breast, Virginia ham, and cheese with our cheddar horseradish spread.

The Monte Christine

Named after and created by our founder. Hot ham, turkey breast, and cheese on an Egg bagel with a side of strawberry preserves.

Hot Ham Cheese

Fresh hot Virginia ham and beautifully melty cheese with honey mustard on your choice of bagel.

Chickenwich

A simple, yet tasty, local favorite. Chicken salad with lettuce and tomato between two halves of your favorite fresh-baked, authentic New York bagel.

The Funky Chicken

Grilled chicken breast with lettuce, and Ceasar dressing on your choice of bagel.

Chicken Cordon Bleu

Grilled chicken breast, ham, swiss, and mayo between two halves of your favorite bagel.

Buffalo Chicken

Grilled chicken breast, buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, and blue cheese dressing on your choice of 24 authentic New York bagels.

Chicken Parm

The classic Italian dish, Bagel Bar style. Breaded chicken breast, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese between two halves of your favorite bagel.

Honey Mustard Chicken

Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, onion, and honey mustard on your choice of 24 types of fresh-baked NY bagels.

The Rancher

Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, onions and ranch dressing on your choice of 24 authentic New York bagels.

Individual Bagel

***Just a plain-old bagel!*** For a toasted bagel with a spread (cream cheese, butter, etc.), head over to the menu section called Toasted Bagels, Split and Topped !

Individual Gluten-Free Bagel

So good you ll be wondering whether they re actually gluten-free. Hint: they are.

Half-Dozen

PLEASE ORDER BEFORE 2pm THE DAY BEFORE PICKUP. We may not have your favorites on-hand. Your chosen assortment of six authentic New York Bagels. List your picks in Special Requests.

Baker s Dozen (13)

PLEASE ORDER BEFORE 2pm THE DAY BEFORE PICKUP. We may not have your favorites on-hand. We don t know why bakers decided to start throwing an extra bagel in with every dozen, but we figure we ll follow along. Pick your assortment of thirteen authentic New York bagels. Just list your picks in Special Requests.

Side of Cream CheesePopular

A smallish side of cream cheese makes a great companion for those bagels with commitment issues.

Quarter-Pound of Cream CheesePopular

What s a bagel without its cream cheese? Honestly... still pretty good. But you definitely won t regret getting some.

Half-Pound of Cream CheesePopular

A half-pound of any of our wide assortment of fresh Lancaster-made cream cheeses.

Pound of Cream CheesePopular

One pound of your choice from our wide assortment of fresh, locally-made cream cheeses.

Pizza Bagel

Open-faced bagel with fresh mozzarella and pizza sauce, oven-baked to perfection.

BBQ Chicken Pizza Bagel

Breaded chicken breast, chopped onion, mozzarella, provolone cheese, and BBQ sauce. Oven-baked to perfection on your choice of an open-faced bagel.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza Bagel

Bread chicken breast, mozzarella, provolone, and buffalo sauce with a side of blue cheese dressing. Oven-baked on an open-faced bagel of your choice.