
The Best Pizza in Berks County, Shop by Shop
The best pizza in Berks County, shop by shop: 51 years of Pizza Italia, wood-fired pies over 900 degrees, rare Chicago deep dish, and the stuffed slice.
Aug 30Blue Marsh Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Bernville serves red sauce pastas, chicken parm, hand-tossed pizza, strombolis, cheesesteaks, wings and salads for dine-in, takeout or delivery. Regulars note generous portions, a cozy family atmosphere, standout tiramisu and well-regarded gluten-free pizza and cheesesteaks.

Popular dishes: Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak Stromboli, Blue Marsh Special Stromboli, Chicken Parmesan Stromboli, Meat Lovers Stromboli, Four Cheese Stromboli, Regular Stromboli
View the full menu (168 dishes)Blue Marsh Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria appears in this post, researched and written by us.

The best pizza in Berks County, shop by shop: 51 years of Pizza Italia, wood-fired pies over 900 degrees, rare Chicago deep dish, and the stuffed slice.
Aug 30Rose is specifically mentioned by name with enthusiastic praise for her welcoming attitude toward first-time customers and personable service.
Our server, Rose, was AWESOME! Very welcoming to us first timers! She was super friendly and personable.
The tiramisu dessert is mentioned with exceptional enthusiasm in multiple reviews, suggesting it's a standout menu item that consistently impresses customers.
the tiramisu was next level!
The tiramisu is amazing!!
Customers consistently appreciate the generous portion sizes and reasonable pricing, often having leftovers to take home.
large portions, reasonably priced
Big portions of all entrees and reasonable prices
Customers highly praise the authentic Italian cuisine, particularly pasta dishes, chicken parm, and pizza.
Pizza and Italian dinners are on point
Some of the best chicken parm I've had around this area!
Customers appreciate the warm, cozy, family-friendly atmosphere that makes them feel comfortable and welcome.
Cozy restaurant with great food and service
Lovely place, cozy family atmosphere
Many customers highlight how attentive and caring the staff is, going above and beyond to check on dietary preferences and needs.
The hostess checked on us regularly and even asked if onions on the chicken cheesesteak would be ok for my 8 yr old
Our waitress was very attentive
Blue Marsh Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a full-service Italian restaurant and pizzeria located at 5027 Bernville Rd in Bernville, Pennsylvania, in northwestern Berks County. The restaurant combines two familiar formats under one roof: a sit-down dining room with table service, and a pizzeria kitchen turning out pies, strombolis, hot sandwiches and other quick-service items for takeout and delivery. The result is a menu broad enough to cover a weeknight pizza order and a sit-down dinner with a bottle of wine.
The restaurant takes its name from Blue Marsh Lake, the Army Corps of Engineers reservoir and recreation area that spreads across the countryside just south and east of Bernville. Bernville Road is one of the main routes connecting the borough with Reading and the Route 183 corridor, which places the restaurant within convenient reach of residents in Bernville, Penn Township, Jefferson Township, Leesport, Shartlesville and the communities ringing the lake. Visitors heading to or from the lake's boat launches, trails and day-use areas pass through the area regularly, and the restaurant draws a mix of local regulars and travelers.
The kitchen works in the Italian American tradition familiar across eastern Pennsylvania: red sauce pastas, baked dishes, veal and chicken preparations, seafood, and a pizza menu that runs from plain cheese to specialty combinations. Parmigiana dishes, pasta entrees and hand-tossed pizza are the core of what the restaurant is known for, and portions are substantial enough that leftovers are a common outcome of a meal here.
Alongside the dinner entrees, the menu carries the kind of items that make a pizzeria useful on an ordinary Tuesday: cheesesteaks and hot sandwiches, wraps, wings, appetizers, salads and small plates meant for sharing. Desserts are made a point of here, with tiramisu among the items that regular customers single out. Coffee is served, and the restaurant is a reasonable stop for dessert and a cup without committing to a full meal.
Gluten-free options are a genuine part of the operation rather than an afterthought. The kitchen prepares gluten-free pizza and gluten-free versions of sandwiches, which makes the restaurant a practical choice for households where one person eats differently from the rest. Diners with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity are encouraged to mention it when ordering so the kitchen can take appropriate care.
There is a bar on site serving beer, wine, cocktails and hard liquor. The beer selection and wine list both draw attention from customers, and the bar runs happy hour with both drink and food specials. Televised sports are part of the bar's character, which makes it a gathering spot during game days and league nights. For diners who want a drink with dinner but not a seat at the bar, full beverage service is available at the tables.
The dining room is casual and cozy in scale, closer to a neighborhood family restaurant than a formal Italian dining room. Dress is informal, children are a normal sight, and the pace suits both a quick lunch and a longer evening meal. Outdoor seating is available in season, which is a draw during the warmer months when lake traffic through the area picks up.
A private dining room is available for groups, making the restaurant an option for birthdays, retirement dinners, team gatherings, club meetings, post-funeral luncheons and similar occasions. Parties planning to use the private room or bring a large group are advised to call ahead at +1 610-488-1088, since the space is booked on a first-come basis.
The restaurant is set up for family dining. There is a children's menu, high chairs are on hand, and the staff is accustomed to working with parents on how dishes are prepared for younger diners. Solo diners are also a regular part of the lunch and dinner crowd, and the bar provides a comfortable place to eat alone without feeling out of place.
Blue Marsh Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria handles dine-in, takeout and delivery, and also provides catering for events held elsewhere. Catering covers the kinds of trays that work for office lunches, graduation parties, showers and holiday gatherings: pasta dishes, salads, sandwich platters and pizza. Delivery is available within the surrounding area, and the restaurant can confirm by phone whether a given address falls within its delivery range.
Late-night food is served, which is worth knowing in a rural part of the county where kitchen hours tend to end early. The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, and service moves at a brisk pace, particularly on the takeout and pizza side.
Reservations are accepted and are a good idea for weekend evenings and for any party of more than a few people. Reservations can be made by calling +1 610-488-1088.
Blue Marsh Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is located at 5027 Bernville Rd, Bernville, PA 19506. The restaurant can be reached by phone at +1 610-488-1088 for reservations, takeout orders, delivery, catering inquiries and questions about hours or private room availability. Hours can shift with the season and with holidays, so calling ahead is the most reliable way to confirm before making the drive.
For residents of Bernville and the surrounding townships, the restaurant functions as both a sit-down option for a planned dinner and a reliable pizza and sandwich kitchen for nights when cooking is not happening. For visitors spending a day at Blue Marsh Lake, it is one of the closer places to get a full meal, a cold beer and a seat indoors or out before heading home.
County: Berks County
Phone: +1 610-488-1088
Website: Visit Website
4.3 out of 5 stars
Based on 969 reviews
5 star reviews
4 star reviews
3 star reviews
2 star reviews
1 star reviews

Winery
Violet Vintage Wine Company in Bernville, PA, offers an elegant speakeasy experience with a stunning 1920s-themed decor and a diverse selection of house-made wines and gourmet food. Known for friendly service and…

Italian restaurant
Salute Ristorante serves traditional Italian lunch, brunch and dinner in Sinking Spring, with antipasti, pastas, seafood, meat entrees, a full bar, takeout, delivery and catering. Guests praise the warm hospitality,…

Restaurant
Mary Jane’s Kitchen in Reading serves a unique Latin-Italian fusion menu with standout dishes like citrus chicken and pastelillos, complemented by a welcoming atmosphere and attentive service. Known for its…

Pizza restaurant
Pizza Como USA in Temple, Pennsylvania, is renowned for its perfectly crisp-crust pizzas, warm hospitality, and unique offerings like indoor golf simulators. Customers rave about the legendary eggplant parm and enjoy…

Pizza restaurant
Paparone's Pizza in Reading delights locals with its house-made dough, tangy sauce, and specialty pizzas like the Upside Down and Sicilian Special. Guests love the family-run atmosphere and the flavorful sides,…

Restaurant
10 West Pizzeria in Wernersville, PA, is celebrated for its flavorful Grandma-style pizzas and warm, personal service. With fresh homemade dough and a menu full of unique options, it's a local favorite for both pizza…

Pizza restaurant
Bella's Subs and Pizza in Wyomissing, PA, delights with its renowned Grandma’s pizza and inventive deep-fried cheesesteak wrap. Guests appreciate the hearty subs, affordable prices, and welcoming in-store atmosphere.

Wine bar
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant in Wyomissing offers a family-friendly dining experience with standout service, known for its endless salad and breadsticks. The attentive servers, particularly Cole and John, enhance the…