
Carrazza's
Carrazza's in Cresco, Pennsylvania, offers a delightful Italian dining experience, featuring authentic dishes in a welcoming atmosphere.
Known for: Wings, Pizza, Ribeye steak, Homemade pierogies, Chicken Parmesan
What people love about Carrazza's
Mike (Owner/Manager) & Catering Excellence
Mike is mentioned by name repeatedly across multiple reviews for his exceptional hospitality, hands-on catering services, and ability to make customers feel welcome, making him a clear standout asset to the business.
The Wings
Wings are mentioned positively in numerous reviews as a consistent crowd-pleaser, with customers specifically recommending the Monday night wing special.
Server Alli
Alli is called out by name in multiple reviews for consistently excellent, attentive service and accommodating special requests, making her a standout employee.
The Meatballs & Homemade Pierogies
These specific menu items are highlighted with particular enthusiasm as standout homemade dishes that customers specifically recommend and return for.
Key Themes from Reviews of Carrazza's
Staff Friendliness & Service Quality
MixedWhile many customers praise the friendly, attentive service and welcoming staff, there are notable instances of poor service including long waits, inattentive servers, and disorganized order handling.
Food Quality & Consistency
MixedFood quality is highly inconsistent—some customers rave about fresh, delicious homemade dishes while others report burnt, greasy, bland, or inedible meals.
Pricing/Value
PositiveCustomers consistently appreciate the reasonable prices and good value for the quality and portion sizes received.
Atmosphere & Local Vibe
MixedMany customers love the welcoming small-town, local hangout atmosphere, but several report cleanliness issues including dirty tables, unsanitary utensils, and a dark, unkempt environment.
Catering & Group Events
PositiveCustomers consistently praise the restaurant's catering services and ability to accommodate large groups and special events with excellent food and service.
About Carrazza's
Overview
Carrazza's is an Italian restaurant located along PA-191 in Cresco, Pennsylvania, serving the Pocono Mountains region of Monroe County. The establishment operates as a full-service dining venue with an on-site bar, offering Italian-American cuisine alongside comfort food staples in a casual setting. The restaurant has established itself as a local gathering spot in this small northeastern Pennsylvania community, functioning as both a neighborhood eatery and an event catering provider.
Location and Setting
Cresco sits within the Pocono Mountains, a region known for its rural character and seasonal tourism. Carrazza's position along PA-191, one of the main routes through this area, makes it accessible to both local residents and visitors passing through the region. The restaurant maintains a casual, cozy atmosphere that reflects its role as a community establishment rather than a formal dining destination. The interior provides seating for individuals, couples, and larger groups, with the environment described as having a small-town character typical of establishments in this part of Pennsylvania.
Parking is readily available, with both a free parking lot and street parking options for customers. The facility has been designed with accessibility in mind, featuring wheelchair accessible entrances, seating areas, restrooms, and parking spaces, making it accommodating for guests with mobility considerations.
Cuisine and Menu
The restaurant's menu centers on Italian-American dishes, with particular emphasis on items prepared from scratch using traditional methods. The kitchen produces a range of offerings spanning appetizers, entrees, and desserts, with the menu reflecting both classic Italian preparations and regional comfort food influences.
Among the notable menu items, the restaurant's meatballs have developed a following among regular customers, prepared in a style reminiscent of traditional Italian home cooking. The kitchen also produces homemade pierogies, a nod to the Eastern European culinary traditions that have influenced Pennsylvania's food culture, particularly in communities with Polish and Ukrainian heritage. This combination of Italian and regional American dishes reflects the eclectic nature of small-town American restaurants that cater to local tastes.
Wings represent another significant menu category, with the restaurant running a Monday night wing special that has become a regular draw for customers. The preparation of these wings has earned consistent positive attention from patrons.
The menu extends beyond main courses to include small plates suitable for sharing or lighter meals, as well as quick bite options for customers seeking faster dining experiences. Dessert offerings round out the menu for those looking for a complete meal.
Bar and Beverage Program
Carrazza's operates a full bar program alongside its food service. The beverage selection includes beer, wine, cocktails, and hard liquor options. Coffee is also available for those preferring non-alcoholic beverages. The cocktail program has received particular attention, with the establishment's mixed drinks noted as a draw for customers visiting the bar area. This dual function as both restaurant and bar allows Carrazza's to serve customers seeking either a full meal or simply a place to enjoy drinks in a relaxed setting.
Dining Options and Services
The restaurant operates for both lunch and dinner service, accommodating various dining needs throughout the day. Customers can choose between dine-in service and takeout orders, though delivery service is not currently offered. Reservations are accepted for those wishing to secure seating, particularly useful for larger groups or during busier periods.
The establishment is equipped to accommodate families with children, offering a dedicated kids' menu and high chairs for younger diners. This family-friendly orientation makes it suitable for multi-generational gatherings and casual family meals.
Solo diners are also accommodated, with the restaurant's casual atmosphere and bar seating providing comfortable options for individuals dining alone. The combination of quick service capability and full-service dining allows flexibility for customers with varying time constraints.
Catering and Private Events
Beyond its regular restaurant operations, Carrazza's has developed a significant catering business serving the greater Pocono region. The restaurant handles events of various sizes and types, from intimate gatherings to larger celebrations. The catering services have been utilized for graduation parties, bridal showers, baby showers, rehearsal dinners, and other milestone events.
The catering operation appears to be a hands-on endeavor, with the restaurant's ownership directly involved in event planning and execution. This personalized approach to catering distinguishes the service from larger, more impersonal catering operations, allowing for customization and direct communication between customers and those preparing their food.
The restaurant's ability to accommodate groups extends to its on-site dining as well, making it a viable option for parties and gatherings that prefer to dine at the restaurant rather than having food catered to an external location.
Payment and Accessibility
Carrazza's accepts multiple payment methods including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, providing flexibility for customers. The comprehensive wheelchair accessibility throughout the facility, including the parking lot, entrance, seating areas, and restrooms, demonstrates attention to accommodating all guests regardless of mobility status.
Operational Considerations
Prospective diners should note that kitchen hours may differ from overall establishment hours, with food service potentially ending earlier in the evening than the restaurant's closing time. Customers planning later dinners are advised to confirm kitchen availability when making plans. Additionally, the menu available at the physical location may vary from online listings, so those with specific dish preferences may wish to inquire directly about current offerings.
Community Role
Carrazza's functions as more than a simple dining establishment in the Cresco community. Its role as a local gathering place, event venue, and neighborhood bar reflects the multi-purpose nature of restaurants in small American towns. The establishment serves as a social hub where residents can meet for casual meals, celebrate important occasions, or simply enjoy an evening out without traveling to larger population centers.
The restaurant's presence along PA-191 also positions it to serve visitors to the Pocono Mountains region, offering travelers a taste of local dining culture distinct from chain restaurants. This dual function of serving both the local community and passing visitors is characteristic of establishments in tourism-adjacent areas that maintain their identity as neighborhood restaurants while remaining welcoming to newcomers.
Contact Information
Carrazza's can be reached by phone at +1 570-595-8500 for reservations, takeout orders, or catering inquiries. The restaurant maintains a Facebook presence for customers seeking additional information or updates about specials and events. The physical location at PA-191 in Cresco, PA 18326 is accessible via the main route through this section of the Pocono Mountains.
Unique Details About Carrazza's
Crowd
- Groups
Parking
- Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
Children
- Kids' menu
- High chairs
- Good for kids
Payments
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Amenities
- Restroom
- Bar onsite
Offerings
- Beer
- Food
- Wine
- Coffee
- Alcohol
- Cocktails
- Quick bite
- Hard liquor
- Comfort food
- Small plates
Atmosphere
- Cozy
- Casual
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great cocktails
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
- Catering
Service options
- Dine-in
- Takeout
Contact Information for Carrazza's
Cresco, PA 18326
United States of America
County: Monroe County
Phone: +1 570-595-8500
Website: Visit Website
Customer Reviews
4.2 out of 5 stars
Based on 168 reviews
Review data
5 star reviews
- 60%
4 star reviews
- 22%
3 star reviews
- 5%
2 star reviews
- 5%
1 star reviews
- 7%
Working Hours / Hours of Operation
- Monday:
- 11AM-10PM
- Tuesday:
- 11AM-10PM
- Wednesday:
- 11AM-10PM
- Thursday:
- 11AM-10PM
- Friday:
- 11AM-10PM
- Saturday:
- 11AM-10PM
- Sunday:
- 11AM-10PM
Location Map
BerksConnect: everything local in Berks County, PA.
8,700+ local businesses with AI-summarized reviews, plus local guides, jobs, and what's happening around the county.