Felicia Fisher's Black Buggy Baking Company

Felicia Fisher’s Black Buggy Baking Company

Nestled in the heart of Oley, PA, Felicia Fisher’s Black Buggy Baking Company is more than a bakery—it’s a community cornerstone where time-honored tradition meets creative flair. As a bakery, professional services provider, and specialty store under one charming roof, we’re dedicated to crafting handcrafted sweets and savory treats that keep customers coming back from near and far. Whether you stumble upon us on a leisurely drive through Pennsylvania Dutch country or order online for direct delivery, you’ll quickly discover why our reputation for excellence stretches well beyond local borders.

Commitment to Exceptional Quality

From the very first bite, our customers notice the difference. “The most delicious pies and cookies in all the land,” raves one happy patron, and countless others agree that “the flavor is out of this world.” At Black Buggy Baking Company, we use only the finest ingredients—farm-fresh eggs, locally milled flours, and seasonal produce plucked at peak ripeness—to guarantee superior taste and texture. Every loaf, cookie, and pie is baked fresh, ensuring a consistent level of quality that has become our hallmark.

Our Signature Shoo-Fly Pie

If there’s one item that defines our bakery’s legacy, it’s the shoof-fly pie. Celebrated as “the best shoofly pie in the world,” this Pennsylvania Dutch classic has legions of fans who place repeat orders and ship slices home to Florida, Texas, or anywhere else their travels take them. With its perfectly moist “wet bottom,” balanced sweetness, and hint of molasses richness, our shoof-fly pie is not just a dessert—it’s a cherished tradition you can taste. Don’t be surprised when you find yourself planning your next trip to Oley just to pick up another one!

A World of Flavorful Variety

While our shoof-fly pie anchors our menu, our bakery case is brimming with equally irresistible options. Sink your teeth into our award-winning zucchini bread—toast it lightly and you’ll discover why customers declare it “the very, very BEST tasting zucchini bread you will ever eat.” From buttery cookies and tarts to crusty artisan breads and seasonal fruit cobblers, our selection caters to every sweet tooth and bread lover alike. If you can dream it, we’ll do our best to bake it.

Personalized Creations & Special Orders

One of the joys of running a community bakery is helping you celebrate life’s milestones with truly bespoke treats. Whether you’re planning a wedding, corporate event, or intimate gathering, Felicia’s personal touch makes all the difference. “Felicia did an AMAZING job creating a signature cookie for our wedding sweets bar,” one newlywed couple shared. She collaborates closely with clients—tweaking flavors, designs, and packaging—until each custom order reflects your vision and delights every guest. From monogrammed cookie favors to themed dessert trays, no request is too big (or too small).

Our Promise: Tradition with a Forward Glance

We understand how much our loyal customers value consistency. A few patrons have wondered if slight recipe tweaks altered a favorite flavor, and we appreciate that feedback. Our promise is to honor the heritage recipes you fell in love with while embracing subtle improvements that keep us moving forward. Should you notice any difference, we welcome your thoughts and ensure every batch lives up to your expectations.

The Personal Touch of Felicia Fisher

Much more than a name on the sign, Felicia Fisher is the heart and soul of Black Buggy Baking Company. Customers fondly note they’re “always sad when Felicia goes in pie-atus,” a playful way of saying they miss her warm smile and hands-on involvement when she’s taking a well-deserved break. Whether Felicia is greeting you at the counter, tinkering in the test kitchen, or overseeing a special-order ribbon-cutting, her commitment to personal service sets us apart in Oley’s thriving food scene.

Visit Us or Order Online

Located just off Route 73 in historic Oley, PA, our cozy storefront welcomes walk-in shoppers six days a week. Browse our daily lineup of fresh pastries, or place your order online for curbside pickup and shipping across the continental U.S. Thanks to enthusiastic patrons who drive from neighboring towns—or coach flights from Florida with shoof-fly pies in tow—our reach continues to expand. Whether you’re a lifelong local or planning your first visit, we can’t wait to share a slice of Pennsylvania Dutch goodness with you.

Join the Community of Devoted Dessert Lovers

At Felicia Fisher’s Black Buggy Baking Company, every pie, loaf, and cookie tells a story—of family recipes passed down through generations, of creative experimentation in small batches, and of the smiles we deliver with each box. From our signature shoof-fly pie and sensational zucchini bread to tailor-made wedding cookies and more, our passion is turning ordinary moments into lasting memories. Stop by our bakery in Oley, PA, or explore our online store today. Once you taste Felicia’s extraordinary creations, you’ll understand why customers keep coming back—and why they bring friends along, too.