What people love here...
Above-and-Beyond Service from Carol Lehman
Customers consistently note Carol’s exceptional availability, patience, and commitment to smooth transactions.
Carol Lehman went above and beyond, and I am very grateful.
Carol was always available whenever I had a question, and very patient as well.
Key Themes from Reviews
ProfessionalismMixed
Some clients applaud high levels of professionalism from agents like Carol and Greg, while others encounter unprofessional behavior from agents such as Patricia.
"Carol Lehman went above and beyond, and I am very grateful."
"Severely unprofessional"
About Hostetter Realty
### About Hostetter Realty
Nestled in the heart of New Holland, PA, Hostetter Realty is a full-service real estate agency dedicated to helping families, first-time buyers, and seasoned investors navigate the dynamic Lancaster County market. With decades of combined experience, our team offers an inviting blend of local insight, personalized attention, and proven marketing tactics—whether you’re buying your dream home, selling a cherished property, or exploring investment opportunities.
### What Makes Us Different
At Hostetter Realty, we believe real estate is more than transactions; it’s about relationships and trust. While some agencies rely on rigid scripts or one-size-fits-all tactics, our agents—led by industry veterans Carol Lehman and Greg Hostetter—take time to understand each client’s unique goals. From that foundation, we craft tailored strategies that blend deep market knowledge with hands-on, friendly service.
- Professionalism you can count on: many clients applaud Carol’s “above and beyond” commitment and Greg’s polished expertise.
- Warm, person-first approach: we’re often described as “good people” who make you feel heard, valued, and confident every step of the way.
### Our Market Expertise
Navigating New Holland’s real estate landscape isn’t just about pulling up recent sales data—it’s about interpreting trends, spotting emerging neighborhoods, and leveraging relationships to get you the best value. That’s where our blue-chip expertise shines:
- Carol’s patient guidance: “She was always available whenever I had a question.”
- Greg’s precision pricing: his strategic recommendations and vetted referrals for home inspectors, lenders, and contractors mean you avoid surprises and maximize returns.
Whether you’re listing a family home or seeking that perfect starter property, we equip you with up-to-the-minute analyses and bespoke marketing plans that resonate with local buyers and sellers alike.
### Personalized Attention from Start to Close
One size never fits all in real estate. That’s why Hostetter Realty prides itself on a personal touch that transforms a high-stakes transaction into a smooth, even enjoyable experience.
- Customized home tours: Our agents guide you through every corner of a property—no guesswork, no “stand in the kitchen” moments.
- Thoughtful communication: While we recognize that timely updates are vital, we’re continually refining our follow-up processes so you never wonder, “What’s next?”
- Transparent pricing advice: We listen closely to your financial goals and offer candid recommendations—so you avoid under- or over-pricing and never leave money on the table.
### Building Community Connections
Our roots run deep in New Holland and the surrounding townships. Over the years, we’ve cultivated strong relationships with local contractors, title companies, and municipal offices to streamline your buying or selling journey. When you work with Hostetter Realty, you benefit from:
- A network of reliable professionals ready to support inspections, appraisals, and closing tasks
- Insider insights on upcoming developments, school zones, and community events
- A team that champions your best interests, from your first phone call through the closing table
### Testimonials: Voices of Our Clients
“Carol Lehman went above and beyond, and I am very grateful.”
“Greg’s experience and professionalism make him an excellent choice for anyone interested in the local real estate market.”
“The entire staff is very friendly and professional—good people to work with.”
We’re proud of the words our clients share. Their stories highlight real moments of care, expert guidance, and above-and-beyond service that define Hostetter Realty.
### Your Next Chapter Starts Here
Whether you’re stepping onto the property ladder, upsizing to a growing family home, or eyeing a savvy investment, Hostetter Realty in New Holland, PA, is your trusted partner. Contact us today to schedule a no-obligation consultation. Let us show you how our genuine professionalism, local expertise, and personal touch can turn your real estate goals into the keys you hold tomorrow.
Categories
About This Business
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Contact Information
321 E Main St
New Holland, PA 17557
United States of America
New Holland, PA 17557
United States of America
Phone: +1 717-354-6416
Website: Visit Website
Customer Reviews
3.3 out of 5 stars
Based on 27 reviews
Review data
5 star reviews
- 37%
4 star reviews
- 19%
3 star reviews
- 7%
2 star reviews
- 7%
1 star reviews
- 30%
Working Hours
- Monday:
- 9AM-4PM
- Tuesday:
- 9AM-4PM
- Wednesday:
- 9AM-4PM
- Thursday:
- 9AM-4PM
- Friday:
- 9AM-4PM
- Saturday:
- Closed
- Sunday:
- Closed