Lehman Insurance Agency, Inc Logo

Lehman Insurance Agency, Inc

4.9(8 reviews)
UnclaimedInsurance agencyInsurance agency

What people love here...

Exceptional Service from Chuck Lehman

Chuck is repeatedly named and praised, indicating his personalized attention and expertise leave a strong positive impression.

I really enjoy working with Chuck Lehman
Chuck is very helpful and takes time to answer questions.

Key Themes from Reviews

Staff HelpfulnessPositive

Customers consistently praise the staff for being attentive, proactive, and helpful.

"Very helpful and on the ball."
"Chuck is very helpful and takes time to answer questions."

About Lehman Insurance Agency, Inc

### About Lehman Insurance Agency, Inc.
Nestled in the heart of New Holland, PA, Lehman Insurance Agency, Inc. has built a reputation for delivering top-tier insurance solutions with a personal touch. As a full-service insurance agency, we specialize in customizing coverage for individuals, families, and small businesses throughout Lancaster County and beyond. Whether you’re looking for auto, renters, homeowners, or specialty lines, our team combines local expertise with industry know-how to secure the protection you need at a price you’ll appreciate.

### Personalized, Attentive Service
What truly sets Lehman Insurance Agency apart is our people. From the moment you reach out, you’ll experience a level of attentiveness and professionalism that prompts comments like, “Very helpful and on the ball.” At the forefront is Chuck Lehman, whose clients repeatedly praise his patience and dedication: “Chuck is very helpful and takes time to answer questions.” It’s this commitment to personal attention—coupled with a friendly, approachable demeanor—that turns routine insurance tasks into reassuring, confidence-building conversations.

### Clear Communication & Responsiveness
Insurance can be complex, but our clients tell us that Lehman Insurance Agency makes it simple. We pride ourselves on clear, timely communication, ensuring every question is met with a thorough, patient explanation. Whether you prefer a phone call, email, or face-to-face meeting, our team responds quickly and thoughtfully. In fact, many customers highlight that our responsiveness helps them feel empowered: no more waiting days for a return call or ambiguous policy details. You’ll always know where you stand.

### Comprehensive Insurance Solutions
Lehman Insurance Agency offers a broad spectrum of coverage options designed to fit any lifestyle or budget. From auto and renters policies to homeowners, life, and specialty insurance, our product offerings match the diverse needs of our community. New Holland residents appreciate having a single, trusted partner for all their insurance needs—“Great people to work with for renters and auto insurance,” as one client observed. We work with multiple carriers to find the right balance of coverage, service, and cost.

### Value-Driven Pricing
In today’s market, getting sufficient coverage at an affordable rate is more important than ever. Our clients consistently tell us that we secure some of the best premiums around: “They were able to find me the lowest insurance rates for me.” By leveraging our strong carrier relationships and in-depth knowledge of risk management, we negotiate competitively on your behalf. The result? Peace of mind that you’re protected without paying more than you have to.

### Staff Friendliness & Community Focus
At Lehman Insurance Agency, we believe that insurance is more than paperwork—it’s about people. Our friendly, welcoming team makes every interaction feel like a conversation among neighbors. Clients often remark on the genuine warmth they encounter: “Friendly, and helpful.” We serve New Holland not just as an insurance provider, but as a member of the community, sponsoring local events and supporting area nonprofits. When you walk through our doors, you’re greeted by familiar faces who care about your well-being as much as you do.

### Exceptional Service from Chuck Lehman
Few highlights in our reviews are as consistent or as glowing as those referring to Chuck Lehman himself. Clients describe Chuck’s expertise, meticulous attention to detail, and willingness to go the extra mile. Whether it’s walking a first-time homeowner through policy options or helping a college student secure renters coverage, Chuck’s hands-on approach stands out. “I really enjoy working with Chuck Lehman,” writes one satisfied policyholder, capturing the sentiment of many.

### Overall Satisfaction & Gratitude
At the end of the day, our greatest reward is knowing we’ve made a positive impact on our clients’ lives. From the young couple insuring their first home to the retiree safeguarding decades of memories, customers express deep appreciation: “Thanks for everything.” That simple note of gratitude is a testament to our unwavering commitment to service, value, and community spirit.

### Why Choose Lehman Insurance Agency, Inc.?
•    Local Expertise: Based in New Holland, PA, we understand the unique risks and needs of our community.  
•    Personalized Attention: Our team, led by Chuck Lehman, takes time to learn your situation and answer your questions.  
•    Comprehensive Options: From auto and renters to home and specialty lines, we offer broad coverage solutions.  
•    Competitive Rates: We leverage carrier relationships to secure the lowest possible premiums.  
•    Friendly Service: Expect warm, welcoming interactions and clear, prompt communication.  

Choosing Lehman Insurance Agency, Inc. means partnering with a dedicated, community-focused team that puts your best interests first. Contact us today in New Holland, PA, and experience the difference attentive, professional insurance service can make.

About This Business

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Contact Information

650 E Main St
New Holland, PA 17557
United States of America

Website: Visit Website

Claim This Business

Customer Reviews

4.9 out of 5 stars

Based on 8 reviews

Review data

5 star reviews

88%

4 star reviews

13%

3 star reviews

0%

2 star reviews

0%

1 star reviews

0%

Location Map