Mays Sandwich Shop

Welcome to Mays Sandwich Shop in Reading, PA

Nestled in the heart of Reading, Pennsylvania, Mays Sandwich Shop is more than just a fast food restaurant—it’s a hometown hoagie haven and caterer all rolled into one. Whether you’re craving a quick lunch, planning a big family get-together, or simply in search of a flavorful meal that won’t break the bank, Mays has you covered. This locally owned restaurant has earned its reputation by marrying the freshness of homemade fare with the convenience of online and curbside ordering, all served with genuine hospitality.

A Taste of Excellence

At Mays Sandwich Shop, food quality is more than a buzzword—it’s a promise. Customers repeatedly praise the freshness of every ingredient, from crisp lettuce and ripe tomatoes to artisan bread baked daily. Sandwiches are generously stuffed, ensuring each bite is bursting with flavor. One diner raved, “Food is always fresh and tastes good,” while another declared the Italian hoagie “one of the best I have ever had!” It’s this unwavering commitment to taste and texture that keeps loyal patrons returning time and again.

Diverse Menu to Satisfy Every Palate

Variety is the spice of life, and Mays delivers with a menu that caters to all tastes and dietary preferences. Choose from classic subs, wraps, or hot hoagies, then pair your sandwich with an array of sides—think crispy fries, onion rings, and those unforgettable sweet potato fries. Vegetarian or vegan? You’ll find multiple plant-based options to suit your dietary needs: hearty salads, grilled veggie wraps, and more. “Very broad menu and lots of fried snacky stuff,” notes one reviewer, while another vegetarian customer applauds the multiple meat-free choices available.

Unbeatable Value

In an era of rising prices, Mays Sandwich Shop stands out for offering big portions without the big bill. Generous fillings and reasonable prices are the norm, prompting one satisfied customer to marvel, “I wondered how this place is still in business. Incredible value.” Another local fan recommends Mays to anyone “looking for a good sub shop” that won’t leave your wallet feeling light. When you combine portion size, quality ingredients, and budget-friendly rates, it’s clear why Mays remains a beloved staple in the Reading dining scene.

Warm, Family-Run Hospitality

Step into Mays and you’ll immediately sense the personal touch of a family-operated business. Owner Bill greets regulars by name and takes pride in cooking alongside his team. “Bill, the owner, is super hospitable,” shared one delighted patron. Staff members are uniformly praised for their politeness and attentiveness, ensuring every order is handled with care. Whether you’re a first-timer or a longtime customer, the friendly smiles and genuine interest in your satisfaction turn a simple meal into an experience you’ll want to repeat.

Ordering Made Easy

Life moves fast, and Mays Sandwich Shop keeps up with seamless ordering solutions. The online ordering platform is straightforward—select your sandwich, customize your toppings, and pay in just a few clicks. Opt for curbside pickup, and a courteous team member will bring your order directly to your car, hot and ready to enjoy. “Easy to order online, quick service,” notes one reviewer, while another praises the curbside delivery for its efficiency and convenience. It’s the kind of hassle-free process that makes lunch breaks (and dinner plans) a breeze.

Community Roots and Casual Vibe

More than just a place to eat, Mays Sandwich Shop is woven into the fabric of Reading’s local community. This family-run restaurant participates in neighborhood events, sponsors local teams, and gives back whenever possible. Guests often remark on the laid-back atmosphere—picnic tables, porch seating, and an open-air dining area invite you to relax and savor the friendly, small-town ambiance. “Well run and always giving back to the community,” affirms one patron, summarizing the genuine pride Mays takes in its hometown ties.

Signature Favorites

While every item on the menu shines, a few standout specialties have become legend among locals: • Veal Cutlet Sandwich: The only spot in the area serving a tender veal cutlet on a soft bun—complete with ketchup and American cheese. “One-of-a-kind,” says one enthusiastic fan.
• Sweet Potato Fries: Crispy on the outside, fluffy inside, and seasoned to perfection. “Some of the best I’ve ever had,” declares another satisfied snacker.
• Chicken Salad Sub on Hard Roll: Loaded with generous portions of chicken salad nestled in a sturdy roll that holds up to every bite. “Absolutely good and packed with tons of meat,” reports a loyal customer.

Come Taste the Difference

Mays Sandwich Shop in Reading, PA, brings together outstanding food quality, menu variety, exceptional value, and genuine family-run hospitality in one inviting setting. Whether you’re grabbing a quick hoagie, ordering a catered spread for an office luncheon, or simply enjoying sweet potato fries on the porch, you’ll discover why customers keep coming back. Experience Mays for yourself—online, curbside, or in-house—and join the growing list of fans who’ve made this local gem their go-to destination for sandwiches done right.