P.J. Whelihan's Pub + Restaurant - Reading

Overview

P.J. Whelihan's Pub + Restaurant - Reading is a sports‐focused pub and restaurant located at 1101 Rocky Dr, West Lawn, PA. It offers a full bar alongside a menu of sandwiches, bowls, wings and shareable appetizers, with a range of TVs and event spaces designed for casual dining, game-day gatherings and private functions.

Menu and Specialty Items (Mixed to Positive)

Customers regularly order signature bowls and handhelds, though portion sizes and flavor consistency earn mixed feedback. The Salted Caramel Skillet Cookie stands out as a dessert highlight, frequently described as “well worth the 10–15 minute wait.” Pub Club members benefit from half-price wings every Tuesday, a draw for regular wing enthusiasts and a perceived value boost on an otherwise higher-priced menu.

Service Quality (Positive)

Service is a strong point at P.J. Whelihan’s Pub + Restaurant - Reading. Servers receive consistent praise for friendliness and attentiveness, with several reviews singling out “Mayce” by name for her warmth, energy and prompt table visits. This level of personal attention contributes to a highly rated customer experience, especially during peak sports events.

Pricing and Value (Negative)

While special promotions such as Tuesday wing deals are appreciated, many diners feel standard menu prices exceed expectations for portion size and overall quality. Families and budget‐minded guests frequently mention modest servings relative to cost, suggesting that perceived value can vary significantly depending on order selections and promotional timing.

Atmosphere and Sports Experience (Mixed to Positive)

P.J. Whelihan’s Pub + Restaurant - Reading delivers a lively sports‐bar atmosphere with numerous screens, game‐day DJs for major matchups and an active crowd. Patrons enjoy the immersive viewing environment but note that noise levels can be high, occasionally hindering conversation during non‐peak game times.

Wait Times and Order Accuracy (Mixed)

Guest experiences around service speed and accuracy differ. Several reviews commend prompt order delivery and correct checks, while others report delays or incorrect items. Consistency in kitchen and bar coordination appears to fluctuate based on time of day and event schedule.

Events and Outdoor Seating (Positive)

The spacious upper deck and covered patio receive strong marks for private gatherings and group functions. Reviewers highlight attentive event coordination, comfortable seating and a more relaxed outdoor vibe compared to the main dining room. These areas are often reserved for watching games in larger groups or hosting small celebrations.

Summary

P.J. Whelihan's Pub + Restaurant - Reading appeals to customers seeking a sports‐centric environment with ample screen coverage, personalized service—especially from standout staff like Mayce—and specialty offerings such as half-price Tuesday wings and the Salted Caramel Skillet Cookie. Prospective visitors should weigh mixed notes on pricing, portion sizes and noise levels when determining fit for casual meals, family outings or game-day events.