
Tractor Supply Co.
Tractor Supply Co. in New Holland is a pet supply store known for its friendly, knowledgeable staff and competitive pricing. Shoppers appreciate the clean, well-organized environment and expansive selection of pet and farm supplies.
What people love about Tractor Supply Co.
Exceptional Service from Jordan
Jordan’s consistent politeness and product knowledge make him a reliable asset celebrated by multiple shoppers.
Cheerful Assistance by Maddie
Maddie’s enthusiastic greeting and support during order pickup created a memorable, positive experience.
Knowledgeable Support from Terry
Terry’s expertise and friendly manner earned high praise, reinforcing shopper confidence in staff competence.
Wide Trailer Supply Selection
Customers value the specialized trailer hardware offerings—like long wrenches and quality hitch locks—not readily available elsewhere.
Key Themes from Reviews of Tractor Supply Co.
Staff Helpfulness & Friendliness
MixedMost customers praise the welcoming and helpful staff, though a few encounters—particularly at customer service—leave patrons frustrated.
Product Availability & Inventory Accuracy
MixedShoppers often find the store stocked with what they need, but outdated listings and frequent stockouts for specific items cause disappointment.
Selection & Variety
MixedWhile many customers applaud the broad hardware, pet, and farm supply inventory, niche categories like welding gear and women’s apparel sometimes lack variety.
Store Cleanliness & Atmosphere
PositiveShoppers consistently note a tidy, well-organized store environment that enhances the overall shopping experience.
Pricing & Value
PositiveCustomers appreciate competitive pricing, frequent sales, and a rewards program that adds to perceived value.
Professionalism & Named Staff Performance
PositiveSeveral employees—Jordan, Terry, Maddie, Jose, John, and Nate—are called out by name for exemplary service and product knowledge.
Online Listings vs. In-Store Reality
NegativeCustomers are frustrated by online stock indicators that don’t match actual in-store inventory, leading to wasted trips and lost loyalty.
About Tractor Supply Co.
About Tractor Supply Co. – New Holland, PA
Nestled in the heart of Lancaster County, Tractor Supply Co. in New Holland, PA, is your one-stop destination for everything from farm essentials to pet pampering. Whether you’re tending to crops, sprucing up your garden, upgrading your home, or caring for furry—and not-so-furry—friends, you’ll discover a welcoming atmosphere and a treasure trove of products to meet your needs.
Products & Services for Every Hobby and Profession
Tractor Supply Co. is more than just a farm shop; it’s a comprehensive hardware store, home improvement center, garden store, pet supply emporium, and propane supplier—all under one roof.
- Animal Feed & Pet Supplies: From premium dog and cat foods to specialty small-animal bedding, you’ll find brands and formulations to keep every pet happy and healthy. Shoppers consistently praise our selection of feed, with many noting that “this place has better pet supplies than PetSmart” and more competitive pricing than big-box chains.
- Farm & Ranch Essentials: Livestock feeders, fencing materials, tack, and horse care products line the aisles. Specialty trailer hardware—like long wrenches and top-quality hitch locks—draws farmers and tradespeople who recognize the “bigger selection of trailer supplies than the big-box stores.”
- Garden & Outdoor: Whether you’re planting spring bulbs, mulching your flower beds, or tackling a full-scale landscaping project, our garden center stocks seeds, potting mixes, tools, and seasonal décor to bring your yard to life.
- Home Improvement & Hardware: Power tools, hand tools, fasteners, plumbing parts, electrical components, and welding gear fill our shelves. While some customers find our welding section specialized (featuring trusted Hobart equipment), our hardware inventory is consistently lauded as “amazing” for its breadth.
- Propane & Fuel: Stay warm all winter long with our propane exchange services, or fuel up small engines and construction equipment with reliable fuel options.
Friendly, Knowledgeable, and Personalized Service
What truly sets Tractor Supply Co. apart in New Holland is our people. From the moment you walk in, you’ll be greeted with a smile—often from Maddie, whose cheerful welcome and can-do attitude have become the highlight of many customers’ days. Jordan, stationed near the front of the store, is recognized time and again for his patience and in-depth product knowledge: “He is always very helpful and patient. Thanks, once again!”
Beyond these stand-outs, team members Terry, Jose, John, and Nate round out a staff committed to delivering an exceptional shopping experience. Whether you need expert advice on plumbing supplies or personalized recommendations for your backyard coop, their combined expertise ensures you leave confident, informed, and eager to return.
Organized, Clean, and Inviting Atmosphere
A tidy store makes for a stress-free shopping trip, and Tractor Supply Co. in New Holland consistently receives praise for its clean aisles and well-organized displays. Customers note that products are easy to find, sale specials are clearly marked, and seasonal items are attractively showcased—creating an environment that feels both professional and approachable. As one shopper summed up, “Well stocked, clean store. Very attentive staff … Great specials too.”
Competitive Pricing & Rewarding Value
At Tractor Supply Co., value is more than just a low price tag; it’s about smart solutions that save you time and money.
- Reasonable Prices: Whether you’re buying bulk animal feed or replacement hardware, you’ll appreciate prices that stack up favorably against other retailers.
- Exclusive Promotions: Frequent sales events and bundled deals across pet supplies, garden essentials, and shop tools ensure you can tackle projects without breaking the bank.
- Rewards Program: Our loyalty program earns you points on every purchase, turning routine buys into future savings—one more reason customers rave about our “excellent rewards program.”
Bridging Online and In-Store Shopping
We understand that online inventory frustration can be a source of disappointment, especially when website listings don’t match store stock. At our New Holland location, we’re continually refining our systems to provide accurate, up-to-the-minute inventory information. Whether you’re ordering replacement grill parts or specialized welding supplies, our goal is to save you unnecessary trips and ensure the items you need are ready when you arrive.
Customer Stories & Highlights
- “I was greeted at the door by Maddie. She was extremely cheerful and helpful. Thank you for the exceptional interaction, Maddie!”
- “This review is specifically in regard to Jordan, who works the front of the store. He is very knowledgeable and polite.”
- “What a wonderful shopping experience! Terry was knowledgeable and extremely helpful. KUDOS!”
- “Bigger selection of trailer supplies than the big-box stores. Found better trailer hitch locks than what I could find online.”
These stories illustrate how our staff’s dedication—from the front door to the service counter—turns routine errands into memorable experiences.
Plan Your Visit
Whether you’re a local farmer, weekend gardener, DIY enthusiast, or devoted pet parent, Tractor Supply Co. in New Holland, PA, invites you to discover a store built around your needs. Stop by today to explore our vast selection, meet our friendly team, and experience the difference that clean aisles, expert advice, and exceptional value can make.
Tractor Supply Co.: Where community, quality, and service come together—right here in New Holland. We can’t wait to help you tackle your next project!
Unique Details About Tractor Supply Co.
Payments
- Checks
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Planning
- Quick visit
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Service options
- Delivery
- Curbside pickup
- In-store pickup
- Onsite services
- In-store shopping
- Same-day delivery
Alternative Local Businesses in New Holland, PA
Contact Information for Tractor Supply Co.
New Holland, PA 17557
United States of America
County: Lancaster County
Phone: +1 717-354-0608
Website: Visit Website
Customer Reviews
4.5 out of 5 stars
Based on 332 reviews
Review data
5 star reviews
- 64%
4 star reviews
- 24%
3 star reviews
- 7%
2 star reviews
- 2%
1 star reviews
- 2%
Working Hours / Hours of Operation
- Monday:
- 8AM-9PM
- Tuesday:
- 8AM-9PM
- Wednesday:
- 8AM-9PM
- Thursday:
- 8AM-9PM
- Friday:
- 8AM-9PM
- Saturday:
- 8AM-9PM
- Sunday:
- 9AM-7PM




