Reading Would Need 50% Tax Hike to Close Gap, Memo Says
A city memo for Monday's 5 p.m. budget session puts Reading's deficit at $29.5M by 2030 under 1% tax hikes; taxes alone would need a 50% jump in 2027.

Reading cannot tax its way out of its budget gap, the city's managing director has told City Council in writing, and the numbers he attached show why: under a 1 percent property tax increase every year, the city's deficit grows from $12.20 million in 2027 to $29.51 million by 2030, and closing the 2027 gap with property taxes alone would take a 50 percent increase in one year. The memo from Managing Director Jack R. Gombach is the last attachment in the agenda packet for council's Budget Committee of the Whole at 5 p.m. Monday, Nov. 16, in Council Chambers at City Hall, 815 Washington St., with "Tax Modeling" set for 6:15 to 7 p.m. (pp. 2, 16-18). The meeting is hybrid, viewable on Zoom, Facebook and BCTV's MAC Channel 99 (p. 1).
The memo is the first posted city document in this budget cycle to put multi-year deficit and tax-rate paths on paper, though it says the administration made the same case a year ago: "As mentioned in the 2026 budget review and now in the 2027 budget review the takeaway is clear" (p. 17). It is an undated email that closes by telling members council "has been BCC'd on this email to prevent inadvertent 'Reply All' deliberations and ensure compliance with the Pennsylvania Sunshine Act" (p. 17). It opens "Per Jaime and Ray's request" (p. 16) and gives only first names; council members Jaime Baez Jr. and Raymond Baker asked for tax models Oct. 19 and Nov. 2, according to the city's Oct. 19 and Nov. 2 meeting summaries (pp. 8 and 5). Our budget tracker follows the budget from the October draft on.
What the memo says
Spending growth is fixed in every scenario: from $129.25 million in the 2027 draft budget to $150.25 million by 2030, "roughly $7.0M annually," driven by salaries and wages assumed to grow 4.5 percent a year "with re-funded vacancies," fringe benefits (health insurance and other non-pension benefits) "compounding at 9.0% annually to $27.39M by 2030," pensions rising 5 percent a year to $22.29 million, and overtime growing 5 percent a year. Debt service "peaks in 2029 at $14.36M" (p. 16). Against that, "baseline municipal revenues remain relatively flat." The memo runs four tax paths (p. 16):
- 1 percent a year: millage "rises from 19.409 to 19.997 mills," and the deficit "deepens from $12.20M in 2027 to $29.51M by 2030."
- 2.5 percent a year: 21.211 mills by 2030, a $27.93 million shortfall.
- 3 percent a year: 21.630 mills by 2030, a $27.39 million deficit.
- 5 percent a year: 23.358 mills by 2030, and the deficit "still grows from $11.20M in 2027 to $25.15M by 2030."
A mill is $1 of tax for every $1,000 of assessed value. A single-digit tax increase "yields between $275K and $1.4M in new revenue each year" and "cannot absorb an annual $7.0M expenditure escalation" (p. 16).
Closing the gap with property taxes alone: "2027 would require an immediate 50.0% tax hike, increasing millage from 19.217 to 28.826 mills," then 32.467 mills in 2028 ("an additional 12.63% increase"), 38.619 in 2029 ("an 18.95% increase") and 42.782 in 2030 ("another 10.78% increase"), "a 122.6% cumulative increase" the memo calls "economically untenable for Reading residents and businesses" (p. 16). Its conclusion: "long-term structural balance cannot be achieved through millage adjustments alone. It will require targeted vacancy reviews, adjusting headcount, strict overtime management, healthcare cost containment, and broader tax-base growth" (p. 17).
For a home assessed at $100,000, 19.217 mills means $1,921.70 a year in city tax. By our arithmetic, 28.826 mills would be $2,882.60, or $960.90 more; a 1 percent increase adds about $19.22 and a 5 percent increase about $96.09. County and school taxes come on top; see our property tax explainer.
Three starting rates in the record
The memo prints two current rates. The 1 percent scenario starts "from 19.409" mills (p. 16); the taxes-alone scenario starts "from 19.217" (also p. 16). The 2027 draft budget sets 2027 millage at 19.217, unchanged from 2026 (p. 1). By our arithmetic, 19.409 is what 19.217 becomes after one 1 percent increase, and each of the memo's 2030 rates matches 19.217 compounded four times at the stated percentage to within a thousandth of a mill, so 19.409 reads as the 2027 rate under the 1 percent path rather than the current rate. The memo does not say that.
A third figure sits in the tax ordinance council will eventually vote on. The Nov. 9 regular agenda lists the 2027 property tax ordinance, introduced Oct. 5 and "Pending – Budget Review Process," at ".019261 mils on the dollar, or $19.261 on each $1,000" (p. 4). The ordinance text in the Oct. 5 special meeting agenda levies "nineteen and two hundred sixty one thousandths mills (.019217)" (p. 5), words that say 19.261 and numerals that say 19.217, under an item line "retaining the rate of 19.217 mils" (p. 3). The city has not explained the gap.
The memo also does not define its deficit. The draft budget balances by using $12,446,300 of fund balance, the city's accumulated reserves, as revenue (p. 1). The memo's 2027 deficits, $12.20 million and $11.20 million, sit just below that figure, as they would if each path's first-year increase shrank the planned draw; the memo does not say so, so that is our reading of the two documents.
What council was told Nov. 2
The city's summary of the Nov. 2 public works review records the request behind the memo. Finance Director Joseph Famiglietti said "a 3% property tax increase will provide an additional $740,000 in revenue and that the value of 1 mil is $1,295,070." Baker asked for "modeling of 2% - 5% annual property tax increases" and "3 – 5 year projected cost increases," saying smaller annual increases "would be less shocking to property owners." Council President Donna Reed noted that the 2026 proposal "included a 9% tax increase, which Council was able to reduce to 6%" (p. 5). The same PDF's parking lot, the running list of council requests, gives one mill as $1,295,570 (p. 8), $500 more than the meeting account says. The Nov. 4 summary records 132 patrol officers against full manning of 175 (pp. 2-3).
Also tonight: sewer budgets and six ordinances
From 5:30 to 6:15 council reviews the wastewater plant, sewers and retail sewer fund budgets (p. 2); the draft general fund counts on $4,500,000 from the sewer fund and $10,881,159 from the water fund (draft p. 6).
At 5 p.m. the committee reviews six ordinances introduced Nov. 9 (pp. 1-15). An ordinance is a city law council introduces at one meeting and votes on at a later one; the agenda does not set the vote date, and the next regular meeting on the posted schedule is Monday, Nov. 23 (Nov. 9 agenda, p. 5).
- The EMS fee ordinance, advertised Nov. 16 (p. 3), raises Fire Department ambulance charges effective Jan. 1, 2027: Basic Life Support from $865 to $1,094.35, Advanced Life Support Level 1 from $1,180 to $1,299.55, Level 2 from $1,210 to $1,880.93, and mileage from $16 to $23.33 a mile (p. 4), the same figures as in our Nov. 9 preview. A Reading Eagle legal notice dated Nov. 16 (ad 2496349) identifies it as Bill No. 92-2026.
- A fire budget transfer to pay the outside company that collects EMS bills, "due to the increased activity by our EMS." The cover says $63,458 (p. 1); the ordinance adds $47,000 and $15,458 to two EMS lines and cuts recruit training by $62,458 (p. 9), $1,000 less than the cover.
- A $37,841 state Fire Commissioner reimbursement for the police bomb squad's 2025 fireworks costs, added to the police vehicles account (pp. 6-7).
- Two versions of a $12,250 Community Development transfer for temporary wages to process escrow accounts. The cover says one draws on the department's own budget and the other on "Finance Contingency" (pp. 1-2); both ordinances as printed take the money from the same contracted services line (pp. 11, 13).
- A $71,370 transfer in the police capital budget from buildings to vehicles (pp. 14-15).
At 7 p.m. council takes up an appointment to the Berks Community Action Program; the agenda names no nominee (p. 2).
What happens next
The capital budget review is Wednesday, Nov. 18, 5 to 7 p.m., with the non-departmental, miscellaneous and agency funds (Nov. 9 agenda, p. 5); the city's budget page lists it at 5 p.m. A committee meeting and regular meeting follow Nov. 23. The tracker records the city's statement that it will enact the budget ordinances on or before Dec. 14; the 2027 trash fee is already enacted (Nov. 9 packet, p. 57).
Monday's agenda lists no public comment period, and the city's rules say comment "will occur only during the Public Comment period listed on the meeting agenda" (Nov. 9 agenda, p. 1). To speak at a council meeting, residents register with the City Clerk by 4 p.m. at 610-655-6205 or council@readingpa.gov, or sign the podium sheet in Council Chambers between 5 and 7 p.m.; Zoom chat and Facebook comments are not read into the record (pp. 1-2).
Sources
The public records this story is reported from.
- Reading City Council Committee of the Whole agenda, Budget COW, November 16, 2026 (City of Reading, PDF, 18 pages; pages 3-15 are the six ordinances, pages 16-18 the Tax Modeling memo)
- Reading City Council Committee of the Whole summary, October 19, 2026 (City of Reading, PDF; page 8 records the Oct. 19 tax-model request)
- Reading City Council Committee of the Whole summary, November 2, 2026 (City of Reading, PDF, 8 pages; distributed to council Nov. 3)
- Reading City Council Committee of the Whole summary, November 4, 2026 (City of Reading, PDF, 3 pages)
- City of Reading 2027 Draft Budget, print copy (PDF, 75 pages; page 1 is the general fund summary, page 6 the utility transfers)
- Reading City Council regular meeting agenda and packet, November 9, 2026 (PDF, 62 pages; public comment rules pp. 1-2, the pending 2027 tax ordinance p. 4, the meeting schedule p. 5)
- Reading City Council special meeting agenda, October 5, 2026, revised (PDF, 10 pages; the 2027 property tax ordinance text is on page 5)
- City of Reading Budget page (Upcoming Meetings calendar; City Hall address in the site footer)
- Legal notice, Reading Eagle, Nov. 16, 2026: City of Reading City Council introduced Bill No. 92-2026 (EMS fees) at the Nov. 9 regular meeting (Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association public notice archive, ad id 2496349; search by keyword)





