Blue Marsh Insurance, Inc.

Nestled in the heart of Fleetwood, PA, Blue Marsh Insurance, Inc. is a full-service insurance agency and broker that puts your needs first. From auto and home insurance to life, health, dental, and income protection coverage, our mission is simple: deliver personalized local service with professionalism, responsiveness, and real-world value. Whether you’re a first-time homeowner, a busy family, a small business owner, or a motorcycle enthusiast, you’ll find knowledgeable guidance and genuine care at every step.

Comprehensive Coverage Tailored to You

At Blue Marsh Insurance, Inc., we believe that no two customers are alike. That’s why we offer an extensive range of policy options:

• Auto Insurance – From standard liability to full-coverage plans, our agents help you navigate discounts, deductible choices, and add-ons that fit your driving profile.
• Home & Renter’s Insurance – Protect your property and possessions against fire, theft, or liability. We’ll craft a homeowner’s policy or renter’s plan that keeps you secure.
• Motorcycle Insurance – Hit the road with confidence. Our motorcycle coverage options include collision, comprehensive, and accessory protection.
• Life & Income Protection – Safeguard your family’s future with term or whole life insurance, disability income policies, and more.
• Health & Dental Insurance – Access individual and group plans that balance premiums, networks, and benefits to meet your budget.
• Specialty Lines & Commercial – From small business liability to tailored commercial packages, our broker services open doors to top carriers and competitive rates.

The Blue Marsh Advantage: Professionalism & Friendliness

What truly sets us apart is our staff. Clients consistently praise our team for being courteous, knowledgeable, and genuinely caring. As one customer put it, “Mr. Schappel is the best insurance agent! Stellar Service!” Whether you walk through our doors, call in, or email, you’ll be met with a friendly voice, a listening ear, and expert advice—never a scripted voicemail tree or endless transfers.

Rapid Response & Clear Communication

Life happens fast, and insurance questions can’t wait. At Blue Marsh, we answer calls quickly, return messages promptly, and cut through industry jargon so you always know where you stand. A satisfied client shared, “I called just after 5 pm … before I got home, I received a call … at 9 am the next morning my phone was ringing.” That level of responsiveness means you’ll never feel left in limbo.

Pricing & Value: Saving You Money Without Sacrificing Coverage

Many of our customers come to us after enduring steep premium increases or patchwork coverage. Blue Marsh delivers peace of mind and tangible savings, often slashing costs by 20–30% while enhancing protection. As one policyholder celebrated, “The quote I received was two thirds the amount of my former insurer for the same coverage.” We leverage our strong carrier relationships to find the best value packages tailored to your unique risk profile.

Personalized Local Service & Hassle-Free Processes

We’re more than an insurance agency—we’re your neighbors. A single call can resolve complex issues, adjust coverages, or initiate a new policy. Customers rave that “the transition from our current policies to Blue Marsh was painless,” and that “changing my automatic withdrawal process was easy!” Our localized, family-friendly approach means we stay accessible long after your policy binds, guiding you through renewals, audits, and claims with the same care we offered on day one.

Expertise & Guidance When You Need It Most

Insurance can be confusing. Our agents excel in unpacking complex options so you can make informed decisions. Whether you’re comparing health plan networks, evaluating liability limits, or structuring a business policy, our expertise becomes your advantage. One client reflected, “Blaise and Rebecca went above and beyond … helped me navigate through the complexities of commercial insurance.”

Highlighting Our Star Agents

Behind every positive review are dedicated professionals whose individual excellence elevates our entire agency:

• Angelina Frazzini – Renowned for her attentive service, Angelina moves swiftly through calls and emails, ensuring even the smallest details are covered. “Angelina … quick to answer phone calls and emails,” says a grateful customer.
• Mickie Shimp – With a reputation for instant solutions and thorough follow-through, Mickie earns Gold Star status. “Mickie … absolute Gold Star (A+) agent/person. You could live 500 years and not find a better, more competent person.”
• Katie Sheaffer – Deadline-driven and ultra-responsive, Katie delivers peace of mind by finalizing policies well in advance. As one review notes, “Katie went above and beyond to meet our tight timeline … had our new policy ready five days ahead of schedule!”
• Blaise Perrone – Known for deep product knowledge and fast service, Blaise explains every option clearly. “Blaise Perrone really did go above and beyond to help me get the coverage I needed and super fast!”

Focus on Accessibility & Issue Resolution

While the vast majority of clients enjoy seamless access to our agents, we recognize that occasional challenges arise. Our commitment is to address any hiccup swiftly, ensuring you never feel stuck. Even if your primary broker is away, a capable colleague will step in, keeping your issue from becoming a “complete headache.”

Join the Blue Marsh Family Today

Choosing an insurance agency is a partnership in preparation for life’s uncertainties. At Blue Marsh Insurance, Inc. in Fleetwood, PA, you gain more than a policy—you gain a dedicated team, tailored solutions, and an unwavering commitment to your satisfaction. Contact us today and discover the difference a community-focused, professional, and friendly agency can make in protecting what matters most to you.