
Bird Seed Selection
Multiple reviewers single out the quality, price, and variety of bird seed as a major draw.
Staff Friendliness & KnowledgePositive
Customers consistently praise the courteous, welcoming, and well-informed staff who assist with projects and questions.
Overview
Nissley Feed & Hardware is a family-owned feed and hardware store located at 223 Mill Rd in Morgantown, PA. It supplies a broad range of farm, pet, garden, and home improvement products, with an emphasis on both everyday essentials and hard-to-find specialty items.
Staff and Expertise
Customers consistently highlight the courteous and well-informed staff at Nissley Feed & Hardware. Patrons cite personalized guidance on project planning and product selection, with several reviewers singling out Gary for his particularly knowledgeable assistance.
Product Selection and Special Orders
The store’s extensive inventory covers hardware, farm supplies, pet foods, and garden needs. The bird seed selection earns specific praise for its variety, quality, and competitive pricing. Shoppers also value the option to special-order uncommon or specialty items that larger chains often cannot provide.
Family Ownership and Community Atmosphere
As a locally operated business, Nissley Feed & Hardware fosters a welcoming community vibe. Many customers appreciate the personal touch and neighborhood focus that come with family ownership, noting friendly interactions and a sense of support for local agriculture and small-scale projects.
Convenience and Additional Services
A distinguishing service is the complimentary carry-to-car option, where staff load purchases directly into customers’ vehicles. This hands-off approach to handling bulky or heavy items is frequently mentioned as a key convenience that differentiates the store from larger competitors.
Store Layout and Ambiance
Inside the store, aisles are tidy and product displays are well organized, making it easy to locate tools, feed, and garden supplies. Reviewers describe the atmosphere as pleasant and straightforward, contributing to efficient and stress-free shopping visits.
Pricing and Value
Most customers find pricing at Nissley Feed & Hardware fair and on par with national chains. While the general consensus is that value is positive, a few reviews note that certain specialty items can carry a slightly higher price tag, suggesting shoppers may wish to compare costs on premium products.
Hours and Accessibility
Limited evening and weekend hours emerge as the main area for improvement. Some patrons report difficulty fitting visits into busy schedules and recommend confirming store hours in advance to avoid inconvenience.
Payments
- Checks
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
Planning
- Quick visit
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
From the business
- Small business

Pet Supplies Plus Shillington
Shillington, PA
Pet supply store

Pet Supplies Plus Hamburg
Hamburg, PA
Pet supply store
Just Food For Dogs
Reading, PA
Pet supply store
Just Food For Dogs
Reading, PA
Pet supply store

PetSmart
Wyomissing, PA
Pet supply store

Quick-Tag
Shillington, PA
Pet supply store
4.9 out of 5 stars
Based on 146 reviews
Review data
5 star reviews
- 91%
4 star reviews
- 7%
3 star reviews
- 1%
2 star reviews
- 1%
1 star reviews
- 1%
- Monday:
- 7AM-6PM
- Tuesday:
- 7AM-6PM
- Wednesday:
- 7AM-6PM
- Thursday:
- 7AM-6PM
- Friday:
- 7AM-6PM
- Saturday:
- 7AM-3PM
- Sunday:
- Closed