Sensenig's Feed Mill

Welcome to Sensenig’s Feed Mill: Your Trusted Animal Feed & Pet Supply Store in New Holland, PA

Nestled just steps away from the bustling New Holland sale barn, Sensenig’s Feed Mill has been the go-to destination for horse owners, small-animal enthusiasts, and backyard flock keepers across Lancaster County and beyond. As a full-service animal feed store and pet supply store, we blend time-honored milling traditions with modern conveniences—delivering premium-quality feed, personalized recommendations, and a level of customer care that keeps customers coming back, rain or shine.

Exceptional Customer Service with a Personal Touch

At Sensenig’s, we believe great products are only half the story. It’s our people who transform an ordinary transaction into a relationship. From the moment you step through our doors—or place an order online—a friendly face greets you, ready to listen and help. Our staff pride themselves on delivering genuine smiles and tailored guidance, whether you’re a first-time poultry raiser or a seasoned equestrian.

Few embody this commitment more than our Equine Specialist, Lily. Customers rave that “Lily is amazing…really goes above and beyond,” offering unbiased, expert advice that makes feed selection simple and stress-free. Her passion for horses shines through every recommendation, ensuring clients leave confident they’ve chosen the right nutrition plan for their animals. It’s this level of personalized attention that turns casual shoppers into lifelong friends of Sensenig’s Feed Mill.

Premium Quality Feed & Customized Solutions

High-quality, consistent nutrition lies at the heart of our mission. We source only the finest grains and supplements, rigorously inspecting each batch to uphold our reputation for excellence. Many customers swear by our signature “12% Horse Feed That Makes Horses Dance,” marveling at its irresistible palatability—so much so that some brave multi-hour drives just to stock up. One customer joked, “My horses will dance for it…they won’t touch any other feed.”

Still, we know no operation is flawless, and on rare occasions a customer has reported an off-smelling bag. When that happens, our team responds immediately—replacing the product, investigating the cause, and ensuring the issue never recurs. This blend of high standards and responsive service guarantees that you receive feed you can trust, every time.

Beyond our standard offerings, Sensenig’s Feed Mill excels at customization. Whether you need a precise vitamin boost, a specialized grain ratio, or a full custom blend, our mill staff collaborates with you to create a feed formula that addresses your animals’ unique dietary requirements. And if you’re balancing fifty-pound bags of feed in the trunk, don’t worry: our courteous team members are happy to load them directly into your vehicle.

Competitive Pricing & Outstanding Value

Quality nutrition shouldn’t break the bank, and at Sensenig’s Feed Mill, it doesn’t. Our customers consistently highlight the remarkable balance between top-tier feed and fair pricing. “Top quality feed and prices are fantastic,” one review notes, while another confirms, “Good quality feed at reasonable prices. They’re not the cheapest…but convenient.” We strive to keep our price points competitive, knowing that superior value builds lasting trust.

Speedy Service & Seamless Convenience

Life on the farm moves fast—and so do we. With streamlined order processing and ample staff on hand, wait times at our pickup window are minimal. “Order filling was fast. Everyone was helpful and congenial!” shared one satisfied customer. Whether you’re in and out between sale barn showings or scheduling a midday delivery, you’ll appreciate how efficiently we get you back on the road, feed in tow.

Our strategic location next to the New Holland sale barn isn’t just a landmark—it’s a promise of convenience. Busy horse traders, weekend visitors, and long-distance patrons all benefit from immediate access. We’ve even welcomed customers who travel five to seven hours from Adams County simply because our feed and service are worth the journey. For those who prefer to stay on the farm, we offer free delivery with a minimum order, bringing your feed directly to your doorstep without added cost.

Why Sensenig’s Feed Mill Stands Out

• Warm, Expert Service: From Lily’s equine expertise to every staff member’s can-do attitude, our team ensures you and your animals feel valued and understood.
• Top-Notch, Customizable Feed: Whether it’s our renowned 12% Horse Feed or a bespoke formula crafted just for you, we maintain rigorous quality control and personalized blends.
• Fair Pricing & Added Value: Competitive rates, free delivery options, and genuine guidance mean you get more than just feed—you get peace of mind.
• Rapid Turnaround & Prime Location: Quick order fulfillment, minimal wait times, and a spot right beside the New Holland sale barn make us the logical choice for busy farm families.

At Sensenig’s Feed Mill in New Holland, PA, we combine the warmth of small-town service with the efficiency of a modern feed mill. Whether you’re feeding one horse or an entire flock, our mission remains the same: to provide exceptional feed, tailor-made solutions, and an experience so positive, your animals—and you—will be dancing. Come see why generations of customers trust Sensenig’s for all their animal feed and pet supply needs.